MNSSHP or MVMCP???

[Iowaswete]

I want to take my DD to one of these next year.......which one do you prefer and why??

HAHA I havent even gone on my first trip yet and Im already planning my 2nd

 

[maci]

WE like MNSSHP better.
The themeing is so great, there are TONS of characters, and the park really FEELS different than it does on a regular day. To me MVMCP just felt like normal magic kingdom, with hot cocoa and cookies.
It is really fun to see everyone decked out in their halloween costumes, which really addes to the atmosphere as well.

Both parties are fun, and I would do both again...but MNSHHP is our favorite!

 

[julsmom]

I don't have any experience to back me up, but I say try MNSSHP. It just looks like too much fun. And I love too much fun.

 

[beattyfamily]

I love them both very much so I alternate each year but we started with MVMCP and did it two years in a row just because I love it and love December at WDW. Now we alternative.

If I had to choose, though, I'd probably lean a bit more to MVMCP but its really tough to choose!

 

[DISNEYFAMILYOFFOUR]

We have done both--MVMCP once and MNSSHP twice. For us, it would definitely be MNSSHP.