Everyone has different tastes. We went on 11/8th and enjoyed it. I am working on our 2009 vacation plan and asked DH where he would want to eat again - and the BBQ was the first one he mentioned.
The food was good and plentiful. The floor show was entertaining. The only negative was the noise scared our DDs at first. But once they got past that they enjoyed it to.
I went to utube and searched the BBQ, and watched other videos that people took of it - and decided to give it a shot as it looked like so much fun. I had read mixed reviews on the food - and was nervous, but honestly - we really enjoyed the food. I had my stomach stapled years ago so if the meat is tough of dry I can't eat it - and I was able to eat the ribs there. My DH said the potato salad was the best he ever had. And my DDs loved the chicken.
So, again - everyone's tastes is different. But for us - the BBQ will be a repeat next year for the food & the entertainment. We felt it was worth our two dining credits.