I was the one who said that.
It was fun getting dressed in Tropical clothes and the atmosphere was festive.
Don't remember what was on the menu but our waiter would only let us order the shrimp with rice dish which was just OK, not great. He said the other stuff wasn't even worth having. We were a party of 8 and 4 of our crowd did stay in Cozumel and ate and drank their. Our waiter actually went over to meet them at Carlos and Charlies after our dinner seating but by then they were back on the boat.
OK, I'm rambling, the point is, we thought the food stunk. Every other meal the entire week long, we were very pleased with but this one wasn't any good. I do remember the lobster on Captain's night was a bit dry(maybe from them freezing them), but it was still good.