We are fond of saying that Disney is not a "vacation" but an "experience" - if we want a vacation we go to the beach!
When my DH and I first went in 2001, we had no idea what "rope drop" even was, park hopped to and from ADRs very inefficiently LOL, and still had a great time - but that was Jan 2001, and it was DEAD, I mean we literally walked on everything, at all times of day.
Those days are long gone, unfortunately. As others have said, what you get out of your trip will depend on your expectations and what you put into it (by planning, getting up earlier, etc) - if you lower your expectations, then you can put in less and have a great time. I know for my family, we would be disappointed to miss most of the attractions (not all - can't say we'd miss doing Stitch!) so we do get up early, drag ourselves to rope drop and follow a very tight plan. When we are running late, we pay for it later - it is a noticeable difference.
FP+ also made a noticeable difference for us. We were there when MK was changing over to all FP+, so we had one day with paper FPs available and three days without. That one day we hit rope drop and did at least twice more rides, including many repeats of our faves, like BTMRR 3x in the late afternoon with no wait (once with FP+, twice with paper FP). The other three days we missed rope drop by 30 min to an hour, only had FP+ and we did SO much less and spent a lot of time just wandering around skipping the 30 min+ lines and settling for less popular attractions (like Tea Cups instead of Pooh), telling our kids, "No, honey, we can't ride that again - we just used our one FP+ for it and the line is 45 min long - we'll miss our ADR and get charged $120 if we try to get in it." FP+ makes it a whole different animal for people with our touring style.
So the big question is - what do you want to get done on the trip? It's hard to say without having been there but I know for me, I am still kicking myself for taking too long at our pre-rope drop Ohana meal in 2012, missing rope drop by 30 min and not riding Snow White because the line was too long. And this last trip, even with 2 days at HS, we didn't ride the Great Movie Ride (one of my faves) because of 30-40 min posted waits. It bums me out to think about it LOL!
But it just means we have to go back sooner than planned
