See this is why you can't use other people's opinions of the food to form your own. The Master Chef Series on the 7-day was my 2nd favorite meal (after Palo). I thought dessert was a bit lacking, but I had the pasta and really liked it. My wife tried the pasta that I had, and I think that she thought it was OK, but she didn't like it as much as I did.
If we were going on the 7-day again (or should I say "when we go"?) we both decided that we would go to Palo on the night we are scheduled for Lumiere's regular menu, since this was our least favorite. But again, this was the favorite meal of a couple of our tablemates, so you really have to know how well your tastes line up with someone else before you take their advice on food.