runDisney just needs to implement a rule that in order to get into the merch area, people need their bib and their ID, and the names have to match. Then they can only buy stuff that matches the race on the bib, limit 1 per item). I'm still trying to figure out what to do with challenges.
I would think that if your idea was in place, people with the challenge bibs would be able to buy any merch that their challenge includes (so Dopey bib holders would be able to buy all of the items). If it wasn’t for the fact that many people think resellers would just buy bibs and take away spots from people that actually want to run, I think this could help.
This really isn't a surprise. The VQ worked pretty well for Wine and Dine, particularly considering it was the first time that they've had it for the Expo - and considering how much people were freaking out in advance. I loved it because I was able to get my VQ # (41), get in a couple hours of prime park time, and then head over to the Expo. It was soooooo much better than what it used to be.
There was a line in the holding area at the beginning, but I think that Disney got better at estimating how long each VQ group was going to take as the day went on. It also help A LOT that the merch was very well stocked. Also, I heard an Expo vendor that was very, very, VERY happy with the VQ because fewer people ran in, grabbed their shirts, and ran over to the Disney merch. Instead people stayed and shopped with them. And since most of the Expo vendors are small businesses, that's a great thing, IMHO.
To everyone who hasn't used the VQ before, do NOT freak out over it. It's fine - really.
I can understand the draw from the Expo vendors. I usually spend the majority of my expo day in the runDisney merch building, and the majority of that time is waiting on line - getting into the building, waiting on the passholder merch line, waiting on the checkout line (pre-mobile checkout), waiting on photo lines… By the time I get through there, walk through the bib pickup building, and then get to the actual vendor building, I’m usually done for the day. I usually pick and choose certain booths to stop at (if any) on my way to and from picking up my shirts. I’m all for supporting small businesses, so I’m glad that the VQ is benefiting them, but I still wish there was another way.
The VQ was super annoying at W&D. I was hoping that VQ would negatively impact merch sales and Disney wouldn't do it again. Guess not!
There is still a ton of W&D merch on eBay. I hope resellers lost money and it will dissuade them in the future.
If they do VQ for Princess, I'm curious how they will handle the preorder merch pickup on the first day. If I just want to get what I've already paid for, I would hope a VQ entry isn't needed.
I was hoping that the fact that they dropped it in the afternoon of the first day would mean that they wouldn’t find it worthwhile to do it again. I didn’t think that would be the case, so I’m not surprised it’s back, but I was hoping!
I’ve never done W&D, but I know the number of participants is less, and I read on social media that the generic merch seemed to be moving faster than the race specific merch. I don’t know if that’s because they actually had enough items in stock to make it possible for almost everyone to get everything they wanted, or if it’s because the race specific merch wasn’t as popular. I heard the race themes weren’t well received by many. Again, I wasn’t there so this is solely based on other’s comments.
I know I’ve said this before, but I dislike the idea of the VQ for a few reasons. First, it reminds me of the
shopDisney merch pass. I know it’s not exactly the same, but it leaves my opportunity to purchase Dopey merch for my first (and likely only) Dopey experience up to chance. Before VQ I could choose how early I wanted to arrive and wait in line, and if I decided the wait wasn’t worth it, that was on me. Now it’s up to what group I‘m assigned, along with my luck with Disney Wi-Fi and/or my cellular data plan.
My bigger issue with the VQ is that it seems to be just another draw to get people to join Club runDisney. I have absolutely no problem with the membership as a whole, but I have a problem with the things they’ve taken away in order to make membership more appealing. When Club runDisney was first announced, the high price was a no for me with the benefits that were included. The one that seemed the most worthwhile to me was the race registration opportunities, but it wasn’t worth it to me because I always used early registration for APs/DVC members. Once that was taken away, the next draw was the early merch access. I was more tempted, but I felt I’d be better off saving the money on the membership knowing I’d be spending at the expo. It seemed like a money grab to have to pay to get in to spend more money. I didn’t see it as an issue because I knew I could make the decision to get to the expo early and wait on line, and at this point I just expect it and see it as a part of the runDisney experience. Now this is no longer the case with the VQ. If these changes were announced prior to Club runDisney registration, I might have felt differently and made the decision to purchase. This is just my opinion, but it feels like they’re continuing to take away from the general runners in order to make Club runDisney more appealing. I wish they’d add perks for the Club runDisney members (like the priority pick up, early merch access, maybe a lounge on race mornings with breakfast, etc.) without taking away from the non-members.
While I know it would probably cost more for the runners in the end, I wish they‘d just offer all of the race merchandise for pre-order, or give you the opportunity to buy any sold out items online and have them shipped to your house. Knowing I will have the opportunity to get whatever I’m interested in (even if it’s after the race weekend) could significantly reduce the reseller situation. I know some people would still buy from them, but I think most wouldn’t bother if they knew they could order directly through Disney.
I’m also curious to see how preorders work with the VQ. The first time I preordered for Princess we were able to go straight into merch to pick it up and still look around. After that year, you still had to wait in the long line to pick up preordered merch. I’m imagining that the same process will be in place for the VQ, but time will tell…