My favorite option for natural summer looking coverage is to mix liquid foundation with moisturizer. You basically create your own tinted moisturizer. I also own an all in one, which is nice if I'm feeling lazy and want my moisturizer, SPF, and coverage in one easy step, but it doesn't look as nice. I then put a setting powder on top. I have combination skin, so I have to moisturize, SPF lotion is unlikely to be enough moisture, but I also have to set the makeup to prevent oil.
I really like Tarte products. I have their setting powder, powder foundation, liquid foundation, concealer, and eye shadows. I just have not been that impressed with drugstore brands, and I try to avoid parabans which is really hard at the drugstore brand level.
Benefit's They're Real (not a fan of the name) mascara works very well. I end up with horrible smudges under my eyes with most mascaras. This one stays in place all day and makes my lashes look awesome. Be careful with the brush though, it's very pointy.
I like to finish the look with blush. This basic amount of coverage takes about 5 minutes. Very easy.