We absolutely love our Boardwalk home.
DH and I bought here partly because of the romantic atmosphere.
We think you will love it!
However, on our trip in April with extended family...we had planned for everyone to stay at POP on our 1st night before moving to BWV. One of my DSIS got upgraded from POP to SSR. In my efforts to upgrade everybody to SSR, I got her upgraded to a 1 BDRM for that 1 night. (I thought very seriously about keeping the points, and booking her at SSR for the whole week on cash.)
Anyway, when she got her boardwalk studio the next day, she was furious, and DEMANDED that we get her back to SSR, and she had a pretty primo Boardwalk Studio. (Dedicated, w/daybed, at corner of village green & boardwalk, with a HUGE balcony)
We had reserved a 2 bdrm non-smoking for me, DH, and my other sister's family, with a smoking studio for her. She also asked that DH and I switch with her so that she could have the 1 bedroom as the studio made her claustrophobic. DH had fantasized about his 1st 1bdrm for months and would not give in to this nonsense. Result, I kept my husband while DSIS stayed mad at me for the whole week, and left a day early. (You know I would have given in if she had been paying.)
SSR had been getting a lot of flack on the DIS at the time, and I really got a good private chuckle at DSIS expense.
Overall, to compare the 2, the rooms are the same size (if you get the same type), but SSR is much newer and shinier. You can't discount that.