Captains Grille was OK. Wasn't on the top of the list. I had the apple cider Pork Chop with apple butter on top and it was pretty good. The rest of the meal was just average. Our server was just OK, nothing spectacular.
Here is a list of bests and worst:
All three of these resturants had
excellent food and e
xcellent servers. I really can't say enough about all aspects of each of these dining experiences, all
GREAT MEALS
that we will add to our must do again list for the next trip. As for atmosphere the California Grille had an AWESOME view. This was our fist time at all of these resturants.
In order from the best:
1. Narcoossee's
2. Artist Point
3. California Grille
Here are some others we mostly enjoyed:
-Spoodles:
Great food, terrible server. She auctually made smart comments to us and rolled her eyes when my wife asked a question about an item on the menu and she couldn't explain it (she didn't think anyone was watching when she did this and the worst part was I don't think she knew what it was to explain it)
-Rose and Crown:
Again, great food. Also a great atsmophere and an average server here. Only bad thing we experienced was a 45 min wait past our ADR but I guess that's free dining for you.
As for bad experinces was had the following:
-Kona Cafe:
this was the second time we have at here and didn't like it. The food is just not good at all. I gave it a second try because everyone says it is sooo good but I probablly won't return again anytime soon.
-The Hollywood Brown Derby:
This was the biggest let down of the trip. Almost all the podcast team said this would be a place they would choose to eat if they could only pick one on property. We DID NOT feel that way. We did not have a good server here at all. He just wasn't around and he took FOREVER. The food here wasn't any better than anywhere else. I could understand this if it wasn't a "signature" resturant but for signature prices (or in our case two credits) I was not impressed and probablly won't return anytime soon. As a personal note, this was the only signature we did that was in a park vs. in a resort. I wonder if this made any difference. Also I guess every resturant has it's "off" nights.
Coral Reef:
Our server here was the only thing to complain about. He was a very nice guy but just wasn't cut out to work as a waiter in a busy resturant. He didn't know what way to go next. Also, this is kind of comical, he was an asian gentelman that couldn't speak very good english and his name tag said Roberto LOL

His famous last words were "I'll be back". I felt like I was being served by the terminator. The food and the atmosphere here were both good. I wouldn't hesitate to go back.
The rest of our dining experiences were all just average. Mostly good food and decent service. They all were places I wouln't hesitate to return.