I think you read more meaning into my post.
Like I said, if I read more into it, ignore my whole last paragraph! Glad we're on the same page.
Saying that a film wasn't the most successful WDFA release ever (TLK still hasn't been surpassed) and saying that it was not successful at all are two different things.
Actually, I just thought that those you mentioned weren't AS successful. In fact, I did look up the figures. I'm not saying they weren't successful at all. But they're not up to the quality that the previous releases were, in my opinion.
I'm not a big video person, and one of my pet peeves about Disney videos is that there are so many advertisements before the movie. I also don't like that there are so many different versions of each movie (classics edition, silver edition, gold classics.... my eyes are going to cross)... but I have no problem whatsoever with theatrical re-releases.
Theatrical re-releases are one thing. BUT, Disney doesn't simply re-release a movie. They give it huge fanfare like it's a long lost classic that hasn't been seen in years. And then that's not enough. THEN, they have to take the opportunity for ANOTHER video release. It all just seems like a huge marketing gimmick.
And you're right, those stupid ads add insult to injury.
In fact, I think theatrical re-releases once in a while could be good, if used appropriately. I don't think that an animated movie a year is possible. At least not to have these movies be the best that they can be. So, if they invested a lot of time and money, every two or three years they could release a full-length, feature animation piece that is to the level of quality and art as Lion King. And in those two to three years, re-release some classics. I'd love to see The Jungle Book, or Cinderella, or The Sword in the Stone on the big screen.
But that's not what they're doing. They're using them as marketing gimmicks for DVD and video releases, and to boost the bottom line. And THAT'S what frustrates me.
A last thought I forgot to add: (not that this is unique to Disney) even if you want to avoid those ads, you STILL have to deal with trailers at the movie theatres too. And I don't know about central Florida, but in Buffalo, we now also have COMMERCIALS. I last saw Chicago and had to sit through ads for a charity for which Anthony Hopkins is the spokesperson, Coke, and the new Volvo SUV.