Legalized cat hunting?

Status
Not open for further replies.

CheshireVal

Can you stand on your head?<BR><font color="purple
Joined
Dec 9, 2003
Messages
6,668
I just saw this article on Yahoo News. At first I thought it must be some kind of sick joke, but I guess it's really true. For some reason, this really bothers me.

Yahoo News


MADISON, Wis. - Feline lovers holding pictures of cats, clutching stuffed animals and wearing whiskers faced-off against hundreds of hunters at meetings around Wisconsin to voice their opinion on whether to legalize cat hunting.



Residents in 72 counties were asked whether free-roaming cats — including any domestic cat that isn't under the owner's direct control or any cat without a collar — should be listed as an unprotected species. If listed as so, the cats could be hunted.


The proposal was one of several dozen included in a spring vote on hunting and fishing issues held by the Wisconsin Conservation Congress. The results, only advisory, get forwarded to the state Natural Resources Board.


Statewide results were expected Tuesday.


La Crosse firefighter Mark Smith, 48, helped spearhead the cat-hunting proposal. He wants Wisconsin to declare free-roaming wild cats an unprotected species, just like skunks or gophers. Anyone with a small-game license could shoot the cats at will.


At least two other upper Midwestern states, South Dakota and Minnesota, allow wild cats to be shot — and have for decades. Minnesota defines a wild, or feral, cat as one with no collar that does not show friendly behavior, said Kevin Kyle with that state's Department of Natural Resources.


Every year in Wisconsin alone, an estimated 2 million wild cats kill 47 million to 139 million songbirds, according to state officials. Despite the astounding numbers, Smith's plan has been met with fierce opposition from cat lovers.


Critics of Smith's idea organized Wisconsin Cat-Action Team and developed a Web site — dontshootthecat.com. Some argue it is better to trap wild cats, spay or neuter them, before releasing them.


In Madison, about 1,200 people attended the Monday evening meeting at the Alliant Center — more than the 250 or so in a typical year, but less than the 3,000 or so who took part in a debate in 2000 over whether to allow hunters to shoot mourning doves.


One of the attendees was Katy Francis, who wore cat ears, whiskers, a cat nose and a sign that read, "Too Cute to Kill." For Francis, "The cat hunting thing brought me out because it was very extreme."
 
I heard that on the news today. Just sickening.
 
What should be done about large numbers of "free roaming cats"?
 
That sickens me, too.

What should be done about them is a variation on the idea of hunting. Any free-roaming cat is free to be caught (alive and unhurt) and brought to be spayed/neutered then re-released.
 

Galahad said:
What should be done about large numbers of "free roaming cats"?


The answer is certainly NOT to advocate the legal slaughter of domestic animals--do they honestly think that every cat on the street without a collar is a "wild cat"? If so, I am surprised I haven't been mauled by the 6 or 7 collarless cats on my street who let me pick them up and play with them.

Hey, people, you don't like having a lot of strays around? Well, step up to the plate, when you adopt an animal, spay and neuter that pet, be responsible and in a few years we won't even have to deal with this kind of discussion. Are these songbirds endangered? It doesn't say that they are--so I guess not. That's just the call of the wild. That is what homeless cats do--they have to eat.

What kind of person would want to hunt a HOUSECAT anyway? The first time someone shoots a pet that got out of its house for some reason, you are going to have major issues. Or when some loser takes a shot at a tabby and hits a kid.

I hope this ends the political careers of all who support it.
 
alliecats said:
The answer is certainly NOT to advocate the legal slaughter of DOMESTIC ANIMALS. Hey, people, you don't like having a lot of strays around? Well, step up to the plate, adopt a pet, spay and neuter that pet, be responsible and in a few years we won't even have to deal with this kind of discussion.
What kind of person would want to hunt a HOUSECAT anyway? The first time someone shoots a pet that got out of its house for some reason, you are going to have major issues. Or when some loser takes a shot at a tabby and hits a kid.
I hope this ends the political careers of all who support it.

A) If they are roaming, they are not housecats.
B) Just because I don't want strays, doesn't mean it is my responsibility to adopt one. I don't want one. Since it offends you so much, adopt them all.
C) They're good eatin'.
 
What really gets me is that so many of these cats are probably tame (or once were) who were just abandoned by cruel owners. They don't deserve to be hunted down like wild game.

Plus, what if a housecat gets out and is shot before the owner can track it down?

:sad2:
 
I would think it would also be helpful if cat lovers would stop feeding strays if they are unwilling to turn them into housecats.
 
While I don't agree with hunting cats, I can't stand it when people have "outside" cats. I had to get rid of my kid's play area because cats were using it as their litterbox. :mad: If people want a cat, they should clean up after it.
 
Figment said:
A) If they are roaming, they are not housecats.
B) Just because I don't want strays, doesn't mean it is my responsibility to adopt one. I don't want one. Since it offends you so much, adopt them all.
C) They're good eatin'.

:rotfl:
You are so silly. Honestly. A housecat can't roam? No one ever lets their housecat out for a few hours? WHATEVER. You think these people with guns are going to make sure each cat they shoot at doesn't belong to someone first? You gonna personally guarantee they're not going to accidentally shoot a kid while out shooting cats? These cats are going to be in regular roads and streets, not in the woods like deer. I hope the people who are voting have more sense than your post displays.
 
alliecats said:
:rotfl:
You are so silly. Honestly. A housecat can't roam? No one ever lets their housecat out for a few hours? WHATEVER. You think these people with guns are going to make sure each cat they shoot at doesn't belong to someone first? You gonna personally guarantee they're not going to accidentally shoot a kid while out shooting cats? These cats are going to be in regular roads and streets, not in the woods like deer. I hope the people who are voting have more sense than your post displays.

I'm sure that you have no problem with people letting their dogs roam free, as well. Perhaps they should let their pet snakes out for a while. The notion that it is ok to let your animal roam free is far worse that killing the strays that spread filth & disease. Plus, cats OFTEN make their home in the wooded areas, coming to populated areas to feed. Put emotion away, and look at this logically. Mmmmmm...cat lasagna.
 
Lizzydoll73 said:
While I don't agree with hunting cats, I can't stand it when people have "outside" cats. I had to get rid of my kid's play area because cats were using it as their litterbox. :mad: If people want a cat, they should clean up after it.

TRUE! Same thing goes for dogs. People, quit walking your dogs in my yard and leaving me something to remember you by! :goodvibes Although they are trespassing, we wouldn't even care about that--it's the stuff they leave behind that is so inconsiderate. The next time my DH catches our neighbors doing this, he is going to dump our cat box out in their yard.
 
Galahad said:
What should be done about large numbers of "free roaming cats"?
IMO, I think they should round them up and assess which, if any, could be adopted out. Then they could give them their shots and neuter/spay them if they are adopted out. I do think they would have to euthanize a large percentage of them, but I would rather see them euthanized than hunted down.
 
Figment said:
I'm sure that you have no problem with people letting their dogs roam free, as well. Perhaps they should let their pet snakes out for a while. The notion that it is ok to let your animal roam free is far worse that killing the strays that spread filth & disease. Plus, cats OFTEN make their home in the wooded areas, coming to populated areas to feed. Put emotion away, and look at this logically. Mmmmmm...cat lasagna.


Dogs shouldn't roam free, but I don't think it's legal to shoot them if they do.
 
:sad2: :sad2:

I have friends in rural NH who have 2 cats. One is an indoor, the other is very much an outdoor, Mainly she wanders around their large yard near some woods.

I would hope if one of the kids left the gate open and she somehow wandered into a neighbors yard, they'd take her to an animal shelter where she could be reunited with her humans instead of shooting her.

What kind of twisted person could shoot a cat? What about stray kittens? Might as well throw in stray dogs too...and puppies. What kind of person could stumble across a litter of stray kittens and say "Gee, there's some tough game..."
 
Just wanted to add that there should also be a stiff fine for allowing a 'intact' housepet to roam freely. (for the ones they find who do have collars)
 
CheshireVal said:
Dogs shouldn't roam free, but I don't think it's legal to shoot them if they do.

if there were a pack of wild dogs roaming around, I'd want them shot.
 
Figment said:
I'm sure that you have no problem with people letting their dogs roam free, as well. Perhaps they should let their pet snakes out for a while. The notion that it is ok to let your animal roam free is far worse that killing the strays that spread filth & disease. Plus, cats OFTEN make their home in the wooded areas, coming to populated areas to feed. Put emotion away, and look at this logically. Mmmmmm...cat lasagna.

YOU look at it logically. I have HUGE problems with people letting their dogs and cats roam free--please do not presume to know anything about me because you do not. My cats have never put a claw outside and never will. This is the LAZY way out. A problem has been created, and people, instead of taking responsibilities for their past actions and searching for a humane, REASONABLE solution, come up with this ridiculous measure. I know people who do let their cats outdoors. I do not condone or agree with it. But it's disgusting me to me that in the 21st century, this is the best lawmakers come up with. I also know cats get out for other reasons, like housefires. They should not be shot as a result.

If this passes, any idiot with a gun is going to be shooting cats. A lot of cats are going to be wounded and suffer from poor shooting. Are YOU going to pay to put them to sleep? No, and neither will they. The cats will suffer and die. Do you honestly mean to portray this as a humane solution?
 
I agree...capture SAFELY...spay/neut.. and set Free Safely.. and my Cat agrees... ::yes::

Dsc00948.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom