Overrated. Generally good, but not a great meal. Has not been worth the hassle of getting the reservation for several years. If there is a reservation available, take it. If not, don't worry about it.
I agree. It was good, not great. Very overrated. I'd take a dinner ADR if it was a time that was convenient, but I wouldn't go out of my way or rearrange my schedule just to go there, and I definitely wouldn't bother for lunch.
I actually canceled an ADR there for my upcoming trip and made one at Le Chef's instead. The CM on the phone laughed and said it'll be snapped up be someone who "doesn't know any better".
I'll be honest and say that I think it's very overrated. The food nor the service was very good during our lunch there. If I were planning a trip, I'd skip over Le Cellier and go to Chefs de France or Nine Dragons instead.