Le Cellier or The Yachtsman?

[RJS]

Which do you prefer for steaks and/or dining experience, and why?
We are likely only able to fit in either Le Cellier or the Yachtsman and wondered what others preferences were...

 

[Skylarr29]

My vote goes for the Yachtsman.

 

[Aimeedyan]

IMO, Yachtsman is a true steakhouse.

 

[CamColt]

Absolutely, Yachtsman!

 

[jess20k]

We just returned from our trip this past Thursday. We did dine at both. We have been to Le Cellier many times, and have always enjoyed it. This was the first time we went to Yachtsman.

We did enjoy Yachtsman, I ordered the Cowboy Steak, which was really really good. There were two in our party who ordered the filets, and they said it was just so so, especially for the price. The other person we were dining with ordered the porterhouse, and she loved it, although she couldn't finish it...it was huge!

Le Cellier though, imo was better. I ordered the mushroom filet (like I usually do) and it was out of this world, as usual. I also love the cheese soup!! The price is much better also.

 

[cosmicrays]

Yachtsmen is so much better.

 

[USAswimmer626]

I haven't dined at Yachtsman Steakhouse before, so I can't provide a perfect opinion, HOWEVER...

WE ABSOLUTELY LOVE Le Cellier!!!

The steaks are cooked to perfection. The desserts are delicious. And the drinks are wonderful. You can even order the speciality smoothies with the Dining Plan. So, I'd definitely HIGHLY recommend Le Cellier.

 

[OKW Lover]

We've been to both and its Yachtsman by far. Sure Le Cellier is good, but Yachtsman is so much better.

 

[MickeyNicki]

I say Yachtsman because I prefer the lobster bisque to the cheese soup, the onion rolls with roasted garlic to the pretzel sticks and the filet with bernaise sauce to the mushroom filet.

DH is the exact opposite from me...he liked Le Cellier much better

 

[Pumbaa_]

I have been to yachtsman twice and had the cowboy steak and the porterhouse. Both were fantastic! Loved the restaurant, the atmosphere, the service and the non-rushed service.

Been to Le cellier many times over the years. We no longer go there - too crowded, too rushed and just not what it used to be.

For the price, I will pay a few more dollars and go to Yachtsman.

As with every place, everyone will have different things they like and prefer. Which one intrigues you the most? Go there and if it is not great, next time try the other

 

[psindone]

Go to the Yaghtsman. Atmosphere, Atmosphere, Atmosphere.......It is
really a better feeling. More upscale than a park restaurant.

 

[Robert P]

Yachtsman is better. Both in steaks and atmosphere.

 

[Tiffany]

Which do you prefer for steaks and/or dining experience, and why?
We are likely only able to fit in either Le Cellier or the Yachtsman and wondered what others preferences were...

The Yachtsman gives you more of a true steakhouse experiance even though if you are used to eating at true high end steakhouses the Yachtsman is not on the same level. For the best steakhouse experiance avaiable on the DDP it is the Yachtsman for the best steakhouse on property go to Shula's Steakhouse at the Dolphin.