Its funny, in considering a cruise again, I thought for sure we'd try early, but you know what...I don't think I would. I don't want to go, get STUFFED, have a drink or two and then sit through a show. I don't want to rush back from whatever port we're in to get to dinner. The late seating didn't feel late because there's a time warp for us on board, we never thought "gee, it's 5pm, we normally eat now, let's go!". Heck, we didn't eat LUNCH even once, because we were so full all the time. I definitely preferred the late seating, and the kids liked the thought (at 10 and 11) of eating and running up to the lab to do what they wanted to do while the "old folks" walked the decks or did some other boring thing. *grin*