I wish I could shop at VS, their stuff is so pretty and I wish I could shop at Penneys (good prices) but neither of them carry my size. The high letter and small band size I wear is pretty much a specialty item (and I'm both too big and too small for Lane Bryant).
And let's not get started on swimsuits...
agnes!
agnes!, I have had a similar problem. Very small band and relatively large cups. Add in to that the age-40 side chub, and I was miserable! They don't make small band bras that are also smoothers and supporters.
I'd taken to buying a larger band, smaller cup (every size up you go in band, you go down a cup, I learned, and vice versa), then doing alterations on the band to make it fit my tiny, but still "well insulated" rib cage.
THEN, Maidenform came out with the new Total Solutions bra. For around $25! It comes in small band sizes! The small bands come with D's and DD's! The bands are wide and don't cut into the chub. Plus, the padding is "age appropriate" and puts the girls back front and center. DH is so happy, both because of the cleavage and perky factor, and because I am no longer tugging, adjusting, and most importantly, no longer whining.
And, OP, I've been "fitted" at very expensive stores, but the best fitting I ever had was from a little old lady at Dillards. Who knew?