Just to show how ones view of an eatery can be subjective and anyplace can have a bad day,check out this review I found on Mouseplanet from a reader:
Imho just not characteristic of Beaches and Cream.
Worst Burger on WDW property: Got to be Beaches and Cream. I know lots of people seem to like it, but we must have hit it on a bad day. The place was jammed, noisy, and no real decor/context. Because there was no table, we got the burgers to go and the presentation was consequently awful. The meat had no taste; like eating the styrofoam carton. The service was slow and not friendly ("outta my way" - ok, perhaps this is part of the "shore" mentality of the resort, but that's more like an authentic boardwalk). They messed up our order. The food was barely warm, while the No Way Jose sundae we got was delivered so early it had melted to liquid before the burgers arrived. The choice of toppings was limited and the cheeses all tasted the same. And the hot dog was literally inedible, with a sour, spoiled taste (yes, our 8 yo ate more hotdogs in one week than the entire country of India - this was the only one he wouldn't eat more than one bite, and after trying it, I agreed). The price was high, The redeeming factors were that the drinks were excellent, and it was nice to sit by Stormalong Bay. Altogether, way below regular Disney burger standards, and that's pretty low.