I'd return to any of them

And we were at the Crowne Plaza. With a car no biggie and we didn't go to DL/DCA on our CP days anyway (did a beach day, a Knotts Day and then a Long Beach/QM day).
I'd probably rank them like this
PP. Very reasonable for an onsite and on the nicer side of a WDW Mod in my opinion, or a lower end deluxe. Room layout was wonderful with the daybed, plus we were the family of the day at check in and got a DCA park view upgrade! Business center was fabulous. Loved breakfast at PCH. Halfway decent espresso. Fireworks from the pool can't be beat. Beds were super comfy.
CP/Sheraton. Great package deal with Alaska, nice rooms and pool. Decent food. Messed up a couple of small things and gave us a comp bfast which was nice. Decent espresso bar. Biggest con was that it was very busy with a couple of conventions and hs dances so long waits at the elevator and a crowded lobby.
Anabella. Great location and back then, quite reasonable and good room for family. I've no idea how it is now, it seems the room categories have changed a bit and it doesn't include the continental bfast but we were quite happy with it at the time.