The OKW GV has a great WOW factor! It is basically the size of Liberty Square but with more bathrooms. It would be a great house to retire in.
The extra 3/4 bath more than makes up for any decrease in size of the master bath. Guests don't have to climb stairs or tromp through the master to use a bathroom. The tile in there IS awesome.
I guess if you're going to WDW for a master bath, then don't go with a GV.
I'm not sure how the kitchen can be too far from the LR. The only way would be to make the GV smaller or put the kitchen between the DR adn the LR, which would be wierd. So I don't get that comment. Personally, I don't think a kitchen should be close to the LR anyway.
Our sink (on my 1 GV stay) was not close to the corner. 4815. Are the layouts different? This was a HA villa, so maybe that accounts for the difference.
Overall, the GV was comfortable and seemed the most like "home" of any place we've ever stayed anywhere. It was inviting, engaging, comfortable, pleasant, well-maintained and the highlight of our recent trip. If you stay in one go with people you like and plan to hang out there.
We will definitely stay in one again!!!
That said, I have two negatives. The main one is the cheap, ugly fake plants. At least dust the wretched things. I bent some of the poor, drooping leaves back up on one of them.
Second is a minor point: the LR can act as an echo chamber, so speak quietly if someone is asleep upstairs.