Key Lime pie......

[plutojudy]

where is the best Key Lime pie on Key West?

 

[FantasticDisFamily]

If she were in Key West I'd say at Shirley's place! I made the recipe she so VERY KINDLY sent along with a bunch of material on Key West over the holidays and it is TO DIE FOR!

Deb

 

[nearlychildless]

I would like to know also

 

[hawkrn]

I asked a coworker this same question when I booked my western trip. She goes to Key West often. She said Crabby Dick's or Conch Republic. Conch Republic has better food if you want to eat a meal there, but Crabby's pie is a little better. I plan on going to Conch Republic-she said you can see all the fishing boats there, etc.

 

[tezb]

When I went on our first DCL cruise (4 day) in 2000 they served the best key lime pie I ever had tasted. When we cruised again in 2001 on the Eastern I was eagerly anticipating this pie again but they did not have it! I was very disappointed...wonder where they got it and why they stopped serving it???

 

[snelsonbrown]

Hey Key Lime lovers,
First off anytime anyone wants me to make them a real Key Lime pie by real Key West conchs, all you have to do is let me know and I will make sure I make it for you - even take it over to the hotel to share with other cruisers - next - I love the conch Republic Restaurant - I go there with my family when we are are down there - the best key lime pie I have found is on the corner of Fritzpatrick and Front street at the Roof Top Restaurant - to get a real one made by real conchs, you have to go to Ms B's on Bertha Street where many old locals hang out -
The receipe is very simple and when I go to Key West, will pick up the Key Lime juice - if anyone wants any, just let me know and will pick it up for you - it is called Joe and Nellie's Key Lime juice)
Short story when I was a single mom in Key West, mr Joe was not only an accountant but our next door neightbor and I worked for him for quite sometime - my mom use to help make the Key Lime pies with him and his family as a passtime it caught on and even tho they have passed on, the receipe goes on)
Anyone interested, just drop me a note.
Hugssssss from a warming up Florida
Always
Shirley

 

[Cassi]

Key Lime Pie wasn't on the menu when we were on the Wonder in January, but it was available from room service! Just ask what the desserts are that day. I was able to get it on two different nights (oink).