Kerry and Bush supporters. A question for y'all.

Originally posted by Elwood Blues
Saffron, thank you for posting the requirements for the purple heart. After reading through it (although not all of it), I found this under the section that lists actions that do not qualify for one.

"Accidents, to include explosive, aircraft, vehicular, and other accidental wounding not related to or caused by enemy action"

Apparently throwing a grenade into a rice stockpile and getting rice "shrapnel" in ones buttocks does not meet the requirement.
(this is the account I heard of how he got one of his injuries)

You can yell at me all you want about his "valor" and "he volunteered" and....

HOLD THE PHONE!!!!

I heard today that Kerry (and I heard this before but forgot) applied for a deferment to go to France (of all places) to study(or something like that) AND that he originally applied for the Navy reserves. It appears that regular Navy service was not his first choice. I will look the sources of this (could this be part of his record that's not been released yet?). But I know you will say that it doesn't matter because he went anyway. Right?

To me it does. It goes to show his character. And it should. I would feel the same way if Bush applied for a deferment but then had to go into the guard as his next best choice.

Elwood is correct about both of these.

One of Kerry's wounds, on the day that he received the Bronze Star, was the result of an unintentional self-inflicted wound. Even Mr. Rassman, the gentleman who backs up the Naval records that Kerry saved his life is on the record as saying this.

Kerry did, in fact, apply for a student deferment. Read his own biography, Tour of Duty, by David Brinkley. He was turned down, and at that point he inlisted in the Navy. He should be commended for doing so.

He should be condemned for betraying his fellow soldiers, and POW's after the war, and shame on the Kerry campaign and the New York Times for attempting to hide that important and relevant fact from Kerry's biography from the average American.

I noticed that some of Kerry's ardent defenders from this thread are now amusing themselves on another thread by posting pictures of George Bush picking his nose.


:teeth: :teeth: :teeth:
 
I noticed that some of Kerry's ardent defenders from this thread are now amusing themselves on another thread by posting pictures of George Bush picking his nose.

How absolutely unpatriotic, disrespectful and un-American can you get!!!! I, for one, am not the least bit surprised!!!

Oh well, what you do expect from a bunch of left wing commies?

:crazy: :Pinkbounc :crazy:

Geez, you Republicans sure lose your sense of humor when the "humor" is directed your way.....

<center><IMG width="250" SRC="http://www.sistersspeakout.com/images/index_01.gif">
</center>
<center>
http://www.winbackrespect.org/ads/</center>
 
Originally posted by peachgirl
How absolutely unpatriotic, disrespectful and un-American can you get!!!! I, for one, am not the least bit surprised!!!

Oh well, what you do expect from a bunch of left wing commies?

:crazy: :Pinkbounc :crazy:

Geez, you Republicans sure lose your sense of humor when the "humor" is directed your way.....

<center><IMG width="150" SRC="http://logo.cafepress.com/5/2952.281325.jpg "></center>

You didn't see my grins, Peachgirl?

I think it's hilarious!
 

Good grief.

Kerry did, in fact, apply for a student deferment. Read his own biography, Tour of Duty, by David Brinkley. He was turned down, and at that point he inlisted in the Navy. He should be commended for doing so.
And? :confused: He also volunteered to be a swiftboat captain. And? :confused: Elwood or Bet? What's your point? That Bush didn't EDITED: [ask for] a deferement so he went into the NG? Is THAT somebody's point? :confused: :confused3 Umm, so? :confused:

And Rassman says where, to whom, that Kerry had self inflicted wounds when he rescued him?? :confused: On record? Care to show me those records?!?!? This is news!!!!!!!

Okay, for the last time, since you both say you read what is posted and since I posted this already, let's take a look at Rassman's own words.

Jim Rassmann: Swift-boat accusers insult all Vietnam vets

Jim Rassmann

I came to know Lt. John Kerry during the spring of 1969. He and his swift-boat crew assisted in inserting our Special Forces team and our Chinese Nung soldiers into operational sites in the Cau Mau Peninsula of South Vietnam.

I worked with him on many operations and saw firsthand his leadership, courage and decision-making ability under fire.

On March 13, 1969, John Kerry's courage and leadership saved my life.

While returning from a U.S. Navy Southeast Asia Lake, Ocean, River, Delta Strategy (SEA LORDS) operation along the Bay Hap River, a mine detonated under another swift boat.

Machine-gun fire erupted from both banks of the river, and a second explosion followed moments later. The second blast blew me off John's swift boat, PCF-94, throwing me into the river.


Fearing the other boats would run me over, I swam to the bottom of the river and stayed there as long as I could hold my breath.

When I surfaced, all the swift boats had left, and I was alone taking fire from both banks. To avoid the incoming fire, I repeatedly swam under water as long as I could hold my breath, attempting to make it to the north bank of the river.

I thought I would die right there. The odds were against me avoiding the incoming fire, and, even if I made it out of the river, I thought I'd be captured and executed.

Kerry must have seen me in the water and directed his driver, Del Sandusky, to turn the boat around. Kerry's boat ran up to me in the water, bow on, and I was able to climb up a cargo net to the lip of the deck.

But, because I was nearly upside down, I couldn't make it over the edge of the deck. This left me hanging out in the open, a perfect target.

John, already wounded by the explosion that threw me off his boat, came out onto the bow, exposing himself to the fire directed at us from the jungle, and pulled me aboard.

For his actions that day, I recommended John for the Silver Star, our country's third-highest award for bravery under fire. I learned only this past January that the Navy awarded John the Bronze Star with Combat V for his valor.

The citation for this award, signed by the commander of U.S. naval forces in Vietnam, Vice Adm. Elmo Zumwalt, read, "Lt. (junior grade) Kerry's calmness, professionalism and great personal courage under fire were in keeping with the highest traditions of the United States Naval Service."

To this day, I am grateful to John Kerry for saving my life. And to this day I still believe that he deserved the Silver Star for his courage.

It has been many years since I served in Vietnam. I returned home, got married and spent many years as a deputy sheriff for Los Angeles County. I retired in 1989 as a lieutenant. It has been a long time since I left Vietnam, but I think often of the men who did not come home with us.

I am neither a politician nor an organizer. I am a retired police officer with a passion for orchids. Until January of this year, the only public presentations I made were about my orchid hobby.

But in this presidential election, I had to speak out; I had to tell the American people about Kerry, about his wisdom and courage, about his vision and leadership. I would trust John Kerry with my life, and I would entrust John Kerry with the well-being of our country.

Nobody asked me to join Kerry's campaign. Why would they? I am a Republican, and for more than 30 years, I have largely voted for Republicans.

I volunteered for his campaign because I have seen Kerry in the worst of conditions. I know his character. I've witnessed his bravery and leadership under fire. And I truly know he will be a great commander in chief.

Now, 35 years after the fact, some Republican-financed Swift Boat Veterans for the Truth are suddenly lying about Kerry's service in Vietnam. They are calling him a traitor because he spoke out against the Nixon administration's failed policies in Vietnam.

Some of these Republican-sponsored veterans are the same ones who spoke out against Kerry at the behest of the Nixon administration in 1971.

But this time their attacks are more vicious, their lies cut deep and are directed not just at John Kerry, but at me and each of his crewmates as well. This hate-filled ad asserts that I was not under fire; it questions my words and Navy records.

This smear campaign has been launched by people without decency, people who don't understand the bond of those who serve in combat.

As Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., noted, the television ad aired by these veterans is "dishonest and dishonorable." McCain called on President Bush to condemn the Swift Boat Veterans for the Truth ad. Regrettably, the president has ignored McCain's advice.

Does this strategy of attacking combat Vietnam veterans sound familiar? In 2000, a similar Republican smear campaign was launched against McCain.

In fact, the very same communications group, Spaeth Communications, that placed ads against McCain in 2000 is involved in these vicious attacks against John Kerry.

Texas Republican donors with close ties to Bush and Karl Rove crafted this "dishonest and dishonorable" ad.

Their new charges are false. Their stories are fabricated, made up by people who did not serve with Kerry in Vietnam. They insult and defame all of us who served in Vietnam.

But when the noise and fog of their distortions and lies have cleared, a man who volunteered to serve his country, a man who showed up for duty when his country called, a man to whom the U.S. Navy awarded a Silver Star, a Bronze Star and three Purple Hearts, will stand tall and proud.

Ultimately, the American people will judge these Swift Boat Veterans for the Truth and their accusations. Americans are tired of smear campaigns against those who volunteered to wear the uniform.

Swift Boat Veterans for the Truth should hang their heads in shame.

--------------------------------------------------------

Now where did he say Kerry's injury "was the result of an unintentional self-inflicted wound. Even Mr. Rassman, the gentleman who backs up the Naval records that Kerry saved his life is on the record as saying this. Where? :confused: Are you saying in the middle of a battle, Kerry threw a granade into a pile of rice in order to get injured? This is a breaking news story and absolutely deserves national news coverage! ::yes::

O'Neill, those swifties and anybody else, even if it's someone here on the DIS, who tries to twist and turn Kerry's words and make anyone who felt and feels like he did about the Vietnam War, ESPECIALLY any of the soldiers who served there, who lived through that hellish nightmare, wrong for their feelings and makes them have to relive that nightmare over and over by twisting their words and stories, ought to be, in bsnyder's terms, "... condemned for betraying Vietnam soldiers, and POW's after the war". !!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I have no idea how to link PDF files, but you can find Kerry's casualty file for his injury that some of you claim was either self inflicted because he threw a granade in rice, or self inflicted because you attribute it to Rassman saying so. Please feel free to look for yourself to verify what I've written here. I've typed in the word (something) when I was unable to read what was written.

CONFIDENTIAL
PERSONNEL, CASUALTY REPORT
A. ASI C-98(something) BUPERS MANUAL
D. WSA SAIGON INST 1770.10
1. IAW REF A AND B FDL INFO SUBMITTED:

Page to (something) CONFIDENTIAL
(something) LTjg John F. Kerry USN 713525/1Iod
BRAVO: ACTIVE DUTY, ATTACHED TO COASTAL DIVISION ELEVEN AT AN THOI RVN
CHARL CE - H INJURY, HOSTILE FIRE
(something) 13 MAR 69, 1550H, HSONG BAY NAP WQ 010780.WHILE SERVING AS OFFICER IN CHARGE ABOARD PCF 94 ENGAGED IN OPERATIONS IN THE ABOVE RIVER, LTJG KERRY SUFFERED SHAPNEL WOUNDS IN HIS LEFT BUTTOCKS AND CONTUSIONS ON HIS RIGHT FOREARM WHEN A MINE DETONATED CLOSE ABOARD PCF-94

ECHO: CONDITION GOOD, PROGNOSIS EXCELLENT PRESENCE OF NOX IS NOT WARRANTED

FOX(something): MR RICHARD J. KERRY, INDIAN HILL ROAD GROTON, MASS

GOLF: NOX NOT OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED. RED BOX NOT REPEAT NOT BE NOTIFIED

(something)TREATED BY MEDICAL OFFICER ABOARDUSCEC SPENCER (WHEC-36) AND RETURNED TO DUTY WITH COASTAL DIVISION ELEVEN.

PATIENT ABLE TO COMMUNICATE WITH NOX

NO FURTHER INFO WILL FOLLOW

DECLASSIFIED
-------------------------------------------------
Acorrding to Kerry's own book, he received the wound in his buttocks earlier on in the mission from a rice-bin explosion. It's grenade shrapnel, not rice, in his buttocks :rolleyes:, according to Kerry and shrapnel according to the casualty report. Does he say it was self inflicted? Does anyone? I'm asking because I researched and all I could find was a quote from his own book saying he received grenade shrapnel wounds earlier in the day from a rice-bin explosion. Wait, let me guess, a swiftie does! :p ;P

But let's say for the sake of saving me anymore arguing, that Kerry was the one that threw the granade that caused the bin to explode, let's play with that ball awhile, then Kerry would STILL qualify for the Purple Heart under these rules and regulations, Elwood:

2-8. Purple Heart

The Purple Heart was established by General George Washington, at Newburgh, New York, on 7 August 1782, during the Revolutionary War. It was reestablished by the President of the United States per War Department General Orders 3, 1932 and is currently awarded pursuant to Executive Order 11016, 25 April 1962, Executive Order 12464, 23 February 1984 and Public Law 98-525, 19 October 1984.

a. The Purple Heart is awarded in the name of the President of the United States to any member of an Armed Force or any civilian national of the United States who, while serving under competent authority in any capacity with one of the U.S. Armed Services after 5 April 1917, has been wounded or killed, or who has died or may hereafter die after being wounded


(2) A wound is defined as an injury to any part of the body from an outside force or agent sustained under one or more of the conditions listed above. A physical lesion is not required, however, the wound for which the award is made must have required treatment by a medical officer and records of medical treatment for wounds or injuries received in action must have been made a matter of official record.

(b) Individuals wounded or killed as a result of "friendly fire" in the "heat of battle" will be awarded the Purple Heart as long as the "friendly" projectile or agent was released with the full intent of inflicting damage or destroying enemy troops or equipment.
----------
His arm was hurt later after the mine explosions rocked his boat. I still haven't found any evidence, but I'm looking, that attributes Rassman to saying either injury was self inflicted.

I hope one day Bush has the guts to release even HALF the records Kerry has, so I get to over them with the fine tooth comb I've gone over Kerry's with. :hyper: I would like that very much. ::yes::

Does anybody know which records Kerry hasn't released yet? That's an honest question. I really don't know. There's speculation that he hasn't released them all, so I truly am wondering which one people are speculating are missing.
 
According to the Washington Post who has requested Kerry's military records, Of the approximately one hundred pages in the file, the Govt can only release six pages without approval from Kerry. So far, he has not given that approval. What those records represent, I have no idea.
 
I just have to ask again, are those of you who contend that Kerry was awarded his medals erroneously and also contend that he was a war criminal, currently writing to your senators, the heads of the military, newspapers, etc regarding military reform? I would think this would be an overwhelmingly important issue if you believe either of the allegations......yet I haven't seen it addressed.
 
Originally posted by Elwood Blues
They gave him medals because he was the one that filled out the after action reports.

You know, as HE remembered how it happened.

So, what is more painful, the dentist or getting hit by a piece of rice?

It was a piece of grenade shrapnel.

Rice is the name of the person who sat before the Senate and lied through her teeth.

http://www.americanprogress.org/site/pp.asp?c=biJRJ8OVF&b=44887
 
I found this in the Washington Post, attributed to Rassman:
As they were heading back to the boat, Kerry and Rassmann decided to blow up a five-ton rice bin to deny food to the Vietcong. In an interview last week, Rassmann recalled that they climbed on top of the huge pile and dug a hole in the rice. On the count of three, they tossed their grenades into the hole and ran.

Evidently, Kerry did not run fast enough. "He got some frags and pieces of rice in his rear end," Rassmann said with a laugh. "It was more embarrassing than painful."

His wounds could definitely be considered "friendly fire", but I wouldn't call them self inflicted. Neither did Rassman, neither did Kerry. You may not think there is a difference, but I do. But I'll keep looking to see if Rassman or Kerry at any time say they are self inflicted.

Oh, and just an aside, that was after Kerry carried a body back to his boat, one of the Nung passengers from his boat that had been blown up after picking up a bag under a coconut tree, a ****y trapped bag.
 
Originally posted by peachgirl
And this comment is exactly how they do it....no facts, just allegations that will cause Democrats to start defending Kerry instead of discussing whatever negative story is breaking on Bush.
peachgirl, again, I would like for you to explain this. Are you saying that my statement is a baseless, untrue accusation?
 
Originally posted by Lebjwb
It was a piece of grenade shrapnel.

I think you're right.

Wasn't it Kerry that tossed the grenade (I bet he wished he could have run faster or throw better) into the rice stocks? If so, and he was wounded by shrapnel, and the reports were that they weren't under enemy fire at the time (or according to the PH rules "heat of battle") his wound didn't meet the requirements.
 
Elwood must have me on ignore. :teeth:

So, let me just ramble to myself here.

1.) Rassman and Kerry both threw grenades into the rice-bin. I believe Elwood, for you to know whose grenade is implanted in Kerry's butt, you'd have to dig it out and finger print it to see if it that will give you conclusive evidence of whose grenade is implanted there.

2.) Read the Purple Heart requirements again. A soldier does not have to be under enemy fire when he is hit by "friendly fire" he has to be "in the heat of the battle". See those quotation marks? Being in a ****y trapped area, that according to SBVT John O'Neill is "under constant enemy fire", in an area that's a Viet Cong strong hold, puts them in "the heat of the battle", destroying enemy equipment .

3.) Funny how you know the rules of the Purple Heart better than those that request them for or issue them to our soldiers who fought in Vietnam.
 
AGAIN - it is not that Kerry is not QUALIFIED to have gotten a Purple Heart. That is not the question.
The question is what did he DO with those Purple Hearts?
FIRST - he used the fact that he had THREE of them to leave VN after only four months. That is his decision - he is entitled to do it. But many soldiers could run to get a purple heart award if they got one for every scratch.

SECOND - when he got back, he established his CAREER based on being a "three time purple heart winner." He even had a personalized license plate made with 3PRPLHRT. This shows that he is obsessed with the fact that he HAS three purple hearts.

THIRD - he allows (or did allow) his campaign to portray him as some sort of walking miracle - having been "bloodied by hostile fire" on three different occasions, when in fact his 'injuries' were bandaid variety that school children endure every day.

FINALLY - to me it just shows the banality of the man. He tries to be something that he isn't. He wants so desperately to be a hero - he just isn't. He wants desperately to be thought of as a "shot up" wounded veteran - he just isn't.

It is Kerry who brings dishonor on himself by USING these events to represent something that they are not - this is what the Swift Boat Vets for Truth are exposing.

IF IF IF - Kerry had just allowed his Vietnam service to be a past entry in his resume - then it would be totally inappropriate to bring any of this up. BUT - Kerry did not do that. He EXAGGERATED his service - he portrayed himself as something that he was NOT. That is what is being challanged. Not his service - not even the fact that he didn't "deserve" the purple hearts. People are just attacking the FALSE image that Kerry has constructed about what they REPRESENT.

It is now undeniable:
- Kerry will LIE to enhance his image.
- Kerry will LIE to bolster a political point.
- Kerry will LIE about thow who oppose him.

But he is not bush - so that is all ok - right????
 
Rokkitsci...sorry, but you didn't prove anything in your last post. Those are ALL your OPINIONS. You cannot on the one hand say he was qualifed for the purple hearts, and then on the other vilify him for having them. All I really get from your post is that no Vet can be proud of the fact that he fought in a war and received medals for his service--instead, they should all just crawl under and rock and be quiet about it. Honestly, I find that attitude totally shameful.
 
The bottom line here DIS Kids, is that Kerry served his country on the front line when his nation needed him, held a position of command and was honored by his country for his actions.


Bush ducked out.

Parse this issue all you want, Spin it all you want, that's what it boils down to.

Opponents wishing to smear Kerry fail to acknowledge that his statements made before the public outlining the horror of war (now pay attention here...) WERE COMMENTS MADE BY OTHER SOILDERS THAT HE WAS REPEATING AND NOT ACCUSATIONS MADE BY KERRY. Did you get that? Do you understand?

So to make it real easy for everyone:

Kerry: Hero

Bush:Coward
 
Originally posted by Lebjwb


Opponents wishing to smear Kerry fail to acknowledge that his statements made before the public outlining the horror of war (now pay attention here...) WERE COMMENTS MADE BY OTHER SOILDERS THAT HE WAS REPEATING AND NOT ACCUSATIONS MADE BY KERRY. Did you get that? Do you understand?


Do you not understand that THIS is spin? And that most veterans aren't going to buy it.? And that the Kerry campaign knows (from their own internal polling) that most veterans aren't going to buy it?,

This is why the Kerry campaign has taken great pains to obscure this part of Kerry's Vietnam service record.
 
When did the truth become spin? The spin is the ads showing Kerry saying things at the hearings, and leaving out the first part of his sentence.
 
Originally posted by faithinkarma
When did the truth become spin? The spin is the ads showing Kerry saying things at the hearings, and leaving out the first part of his sentence.

Because leaving out the first part of the sentence is immaterial to the political context and the intent of his words at the time he gave that speech.

The only way this isn't spin is if the Kerry campaign is trying to imply that Kerry wasn't really a leader in the anti-war movement but in reality, he was just some court reporter reading back a transcript from the Winter Soldier investigation.
 
Hearing ( I forget the exact quotes ) something along the lines of "I have been told that" is immaterial? Have you seen both clips and seen the difference in the impact of the statement with and without the first sentence? You may well believe it is immaterial, I most certainly do not.

I will not diasgree with you about Kerry's activities after the war. But the ad the SBVs put out about it, like everything else they did, is deceptive. Actually I am mistaken, this ad is deceptive, the first one was outright lying. They should never have risked their credibility on that first ad. They could have profited much more on the second one had they not already been exposed.
 




New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top