I have done 2 four night cruises on the Wonder and 2 7 night Easterns on the Magic. The first night, crossing the Gulfstream, was an issue just once, the first night on this year's January 16th Wonder, which was my 3rd
DCL cruise, 4th cruise overall. DW didn't make it through dinner, and by 11pm I felt quesy myself but didnt take anything beyond sipping a ginger ale at the show. DS, 8 at the time, was fine. seas were probably 16 feet or so, and the creaking to be heard was pretty dramatic. By 3-4 am, the ship was calm, I felt better, and DW woke up fine. We wore no patches. She wore a patch for the April 2nd Eastern a few months later, I still did not, and no problems. I wore no patch for either previous DCL cruise, and I dont think DW did, either, and no problems. We both wore patches for our first cruise, 4 nights
RCCL out of San Juan.
I favor the longer cruises over the shorter based upon what percentage of the trip is spent in the "crossing the gulfstream" phase of travel. Never had problems on the days at sea going to or from the eastern caribbean. But a rough first and last night on a 3 or 4 day cruise, that is a significant chunk of the trip "at risk" for not feeling well. I can do roller coasters, but spinningrides at amusement parks get me nauseated big time, so I am not a cast iron immune stomach kind of guy. But so far, with 26 lifetimes nights of cruising, I've had one bad night of motion sickness. Those stats may change if indeed I stick with the current dates for mext DCL cruise, during hurricane season, though later in the season in October, in 2006, and we'll see what 4 nights or western caribbean in February feels like on RCCL out of port everglades in 8 months.
everyone is different--the patch, put on before boarding or at boarding time, works very well, and i dont think most people would have more to fear from the longer cruises, but there are definitely some for whom that is not true, either. Which is why many of us start with the short cruise, to address our fear of "what if I get seasick?" and being stuck on full week's cruise. The irony, I believe, is that the 4 nighter may often seem more nauseating more of the time for those affected.
We're all guilty here of forgetting that cruising just isn't for everyone. But we hope we can encourage people to give it a try to make sure they arent chickening out unnecessarily.