I'll play along! My MIL does her shopping at the local thrift store (not that there's anything wrong with that!). Last Christmas, she bought my 10 year old son a box kite. It was obviously from the thrift store, as she didn't bother to remove the price sticker. DS took the kite out of the box, and first noticed that the string was all tangled. He spent hours untangling the string, and then realized it didn't matter, it was missing several key pieces.
I'm sure MIL thought that since it was a big present, it would be wonderful. We chuckled over it, and then my DS called and thanked her for it.
Please, Jill, post your story!! I look forward to it all year long! It makes me feel not so alone!