Italian Restaurant?

[MJMcBride]

I would like to know if you had to choose between Il Mulino at the Swan or Portobello Yacht Club at DTD. Which would you pick and why?

Thanks

 

[ThisMomLuvsDisney]

No question for me it's Portabello

It's my favorite place to eat in all of Disney World! I always eat there at least once during a Disney trip, and love it enough to pay "out of pocket" even when we have the Disney Dining Plan (since it's not on the plan).

Great food and wonderful atmosphere too!

 

[MJMcBride]

No question for me it's Portabello

It's my favorite place to eat in all of Disney World! I always eat there at least once during a Disney trip, and love it enough to pay "out of pocket" even when we have the Disney Dining Plan (since it's not on the plan).

Great food and wonderful atmosphere too!

I ate there years ago (decades really) ago

 

[MJMcBride]

bump for votes

 

[Robert P]

We ate at Il Mulino last week. Amazing!
It is comparable, maybe better, than Palio (at the Swan also) ever was.
My review is coming soon, but having close friends who have eaten at Portobello, I feel sure saying Il Mulino was the right choice for us.

 

[CamColt]

We ate at both in May and werent thrilled with either. I voted for Il Mulino mainly because they have a larger menu whereas at PYC I was really limited as to what items I would eat (I ended up with pizza).

 

[MJMcBride]

We ate at both in May and werent thrilled with either. I voted for Il Mulino mainly because they have a larger menu whereas at PYC I was really limited as to what items I would eat (I ended up with pizza).

Il Mulino does have a bigger menu

 

[Uncleromulus]

I always liked Portobello and have yet to try Il Mulino. BuT as has been noted, the menu at Il Mulino seems more extensive--and to me, more "Italian". And since that's the category, I voted Il Mulino.