Is Ray Nagin a Racist?

castlegazer said:
YES! And I wonder how Harry Connick Jr. feels about his comments, or how Anne Rice feels about it - or many of the other white residents of this very racially mixed city.

It totally ticked me off. I was further incensed by his God is mad comment. What an idiot!

Well, I'm not Harry Connick Jr. or Anne Rice (who don't live here anyway), but I am a white New Orleanian, and I think he's a racist and an idiot.

I've enjoyed reading all of your comments, but I'm sorry y'all just can't understand what it's like here. Reading about it, seeing it on TV and even visiting can't impart what it feels like to have to be here everyday.

I really, really want to rebuild this city. I love it and it is where my heart is now and always will be. But, this is just too much. It's getting hard to want to stay here.

This next election can't come soon enough. I just hope there are some qualified candidates who are willing to get into this mess.

I don't know how coherent this is and I really want to say so much more, but I just can't. The right words won't come.
 
I think that lots of politicians - black and white - really "play to their audience" at MLK Day celebrations, not pausing to think that the speech will play differently when reported in the national press.
 
missypie said:
I think that lots of politicians - black and white - really "play to their audience" at MLK Day celebrations, not pausing to think that the speech will play differently when reported in the national press.
Too true. They often forget this axiom: Write it as if it's going to be published on the front page of the NYT. Speak and act as if you're being broadcast on live TV/radio. If all politicians remembered that, we'd have fewer blurbs like Nagin's to dissect.
 

He is a racist, an idiot, and an embarrassment to Louisiana I wish he would go away.

He is also showing signs of mental problems. He is having imaginary conversations with dead people and apparently hears voices in his head he thinks is god.
 
Absolutely he is a racist! He is also an embarrassment to his race, his city, his state and to Americans as a whole. It is people like him who divide, not bring together.

Imagine the backlash if a white mayor made such a comment in favor of whites, like Nagin did for the blacks, or any other race substituted here for that matter. Imagine how all of the races (except blacks) feel who have poured their dollars and hard work into making New Orleans what it once was. And to come from their idiot mayor, no less.

And to add God into his statements like he did. What a loser! ::yes::
 
eeyore kelly said:
He is also showing signs of mental problems. He is having imaginary conversations with dead people and apparently hears voices in his head he thinks is god.


Really?

That may explain some of his comments.

If he's really ill, I hope he gets help. He, of all people, is going to need it in his job.
 
I don't think he sounded racist. He isn't saying anything about Blacks being a superior race or whites being inferior. I think he sounds a little "off" (maybe post -tramatic stress :confused3 ) That whole chocolate scenerio is weird!!
 
I believe that people who are racists are idiots and this man is both.
 
disneyaggie said:
Absolutely he is a racist! He is also an embarrassment to his race, his city, his state and to Americans as a whole. It is people like him who divide, not bring together.

Imagine the backlash if a white mayor made such a comment in favor of whites, like Nagin did for the blacks, or any other race substituted here for that matter. Imagine how all of the races (except blacks) feel who have poured their dollars and hard work into making New Orleans what it once was. And to come from their idiot mayor, no less.

::yes::

It doesn't happen often, but I'm agreeing with an Aggie! Hook 'em!!!
 
Muffin said:
Well, I'm not Harry Connick Jr. or Anne Rice (who don't live here anyway), but I am a white New Orleanian, and I think he's a racist and an idiot.

I've enjoyed reading all of your comments, but I'm sorry y'all just can't understand what it's like here. Reading about it, seeing it on TV and even visiting can't impart what it feels like to have to be here everyday.

I really, really want to rebuild this city. I love it and it is where my heart is now and always will be. But, this is just too much. It's getting hard to want to stay here.

This next election can't come soon enough. I just hope there are some qualified candidates who are willing to get into this mess.

I don't know how coherent this is and I really want to say so much more, but I just can't. The right words won't come.

:hug: I am sorry for the pain that you are going through. You are correct, I can not fully understand the depth of what you have experienced. I hope that things are better for you soon.
 
The answer to the question as to why a racisit comment from a African American would not recieve the same outrage as a racist comment from a white person, maybe has something to do with the history of this country? :confused3

Slavery, lynching, Jim Crowe laws etc. It's only been 50 years since we as a nation have gotten rid of our racist laws.
 
Deb in IA said:
Really?

That may explain some of his comments.

If he's really ill, I hope he gets help. He, of all people, is going to need it in his job.
Joking that he may appear to have “post-Katrina stress disorder,” Nagin, who is black, talked of an imaginary conversation with the late civil rights leader. They “talked,” he said, while he was thinking Monday about what to say at the ceremony outside City Hall to kick off a walking parade in King’s honor.

“I said, ‘What is it going to take for us to move on and live your dream and make it a reality?’ He said, ‘I don’t think that we need to pay attention any more as much about other folks and racists on the other side.’ He said, ‘The thing we need to focus on as a community — black folks I’m talking about — is ourselves.”’
http://www.2theadvocate.com/news/2210102.html
 
And here's his apology:
http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/storie...AOL-?SITE=LABAT&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT

Jan 17, 4:24 PM EST

Mayor apologizes for MLK Day remarks

By BRETT MARTEL
Associated Press Writer

NEW ORLEANS (AP) -- Mayor Ray Nagin apologized Tuesday for a Martin Luther King Day speech in which he predicted New Orleans would be a "chocolate city" and asserted that "God was mad at America."

"I said some things that were totally inappropriate. ... It shouldn't have happened," Nagin said, explaining he was caught up in the moment as he spoke to mostly black spectators, many of them fearful of being shut out of the city's redevelopment.

During the speech Monday, Nagin said repeated hurricanes that destroyed parts of America's coast and exerted stress upon the nation were a sign of God's anger toward the country, as well as black communities that hadn't done enough to fight crime. He also said New Orleans has to be a majority African-American city because "it's the way God wants it to be."

Excluding suburbs, New Orleans was more than 65 percent black before Hurricane Katrina. The storm displaced about three-quarters of the city's population. Most of the estimated 125,000 residents who have been able to return are white.

When Nagin, a former cable company executive and political novice, was elected in 2002, he received about 90 percent of the white vote, according to polls conducted by Ed Renwick, the director of Loyola University's Institute of Politics.

Nagin received less than half the black vote, Renwick said Tuesday, and the mayor's heaviest criticism since taking office has come from rival political factions in the black community, many of whom have portrayed him as an "Uncle Tom" figure who caters to the interests of white businessmen.

Nagin has been trying harder to gain the trust of black residents, but in attempting to do so he may have offended much of the base that got him elected, Renwick said.

"Obviously, blacks were the weaker portion of his victory margin, but some of the remarks he made Monday will possibly dampen enthusiasm among some whites," Renwick said. "It seemed to be another Nagin-being-Nagin. He has a penchant for just speaking off the cuff and not thinking it through."

Renwick added: "He also tends to speak to the literal audience he's with at the time instead of the whole world he reaches through the TV, radio and print media."

Nagin said his comments about God were inappropriate and stemmed from a private conversation he had with a minister earlier. "I need to be more sensitive and more aware of what I'm saying," he acknowledged Tuesday.

Nagin said his speech was really meant to convey that blacks were a vital part of New Orleans' history and culture and should be encouraged to return.

"I want everyone to be welcome in New Orleans - black, white, Asian, everybody," he said.

Nagin said the other main point he'd hoped to make Monday was that when blacks do return, they must work to stamp out the crime and political infighting that have held them back.

© 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Learn more about our Privacy Policy.
 
Muffin said:
Well, I'm not Harry Connick Jr. or Anne Rice (who don't live here anyway), but I am a white New Orleanian, and I think he's a racist and an idiot.

I've enjoyed reading all of your comments, but I'm sorry y'all just can't understand what it's like here. Reading about it, seeing it on TV and even visiting can't impart what it feels like to have to be here everyday.

I really, really want to rebuild this city. I love it and it is where my heart is now and always will be. But, this is just too much. It's getting hard to want to stay here.

This next election can't come soon enough. I just hope there are some qualified candidates who are willing to get into this mess.

I don't know how coherent this is and I really want to say so much more, but I just can't. The right words won't come.
:hug:

Can't imagine what it must be like. :(

As for the OP question, I jsut have to say he sure said some strange stuff, not sure what he was thinking.
 
I found his comments offensive. I live in Washington and it really bothers me when I hear people refer to the city as "chocolate city." This city belongs to ALL residents, not just those who are from a particular race.
 
"How do I ensure that New Orleans is not overrun by Mexican workers?"

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/10/07/katrina/main926540.shtml

He said that back in October.

I feel that he is very exclusionary. That, to me, is racist, preferring one race over another. I don't know what else to call it.

You know, it is very sad, what has happened. But the truth of the matter is that New Orleans will never be the same. Why can't ALL people be embraced without regard for the color of their skin, but for the content of their character, as the great Dr. King wanted?

I just don't understand.

For those of you in the New Orleans area, I feel sorry. I know that you have a beautiful state, rich in wonderful culture and history. But frankly, I don't want a damn thing to do with you anymore. The attitude is absolutely astonishing.

My city has done nothing but open its arms to the Katrina Survivors, and the only things that have happened is that our city treasury is draining, our school are overcrowded, and our crime rate is going up. We give until we can't give any more and all I hear is "What you got ain't good enough." Then I see people who have supposedly lost "everything" walking around here with what I call the luxuries of life, expensive hair extensions and fingernails.

Yes, PLEASE rebuild so all these people can go HOME. If they will go home. All I have heard - over and over - is "We didn't know how bad we had it! We ain't never going home!" Oh goody.

Y'all should elect someone who has two bits of sense and can make us forget that all of this ever happened and invite us to come and spend our money there again. I mean, to the nation, this man IS YOU. Is this who you are?

I can GUAR-ON-TEE that on my next trip to WDW my car is getting gas in Texas and it isn't stopping until I hit Alabama.
 
Referring to Ray Nagin as an idiot is an insult to idiots.

I wish ALL the citizens of NO better luck in the next mayoral election and hope they will vote into office a person who will represent everyone, not just one segment of the populataion.
 
disfanatiks and Dan Murphy,
Thanks for the kind words. It'll be a long, long time before this city gets on her feet again and the kindness of strangers from all over the world that we have received has meant more to us than we will ever be able to express. Hopefully, this city will become healthy enough to be able to provide the same kind of support to others if they would ever need need it.

And thanks to anyone else reading this who may have helped a Katrina victim.

Boston Tea Party said:
For those of you in the New Orleans area, I feel sorry. I know that you have a beautiful state, rich in wonderful culture and history. But frankly, I don't want a damn thing to do with you anymore. The attitude is absolutely astonishing.

Boston Tea Party
You sound like you might be from somewhere in Texas (maybe Houston?). I didn't evacuate, but I would still like to say thanks for everything your state and cities did for our residents. I don't know what else to say except that unfortunately the majority of New Orleans residents elected an idiot and now we all have to deal with it. I hope you someday have a change of heart. Not everyone here shares Nagin's attitude.

I think Nagin has lost it. He needs to step down or be impeached or whatever they do to mayors. But I can't imagine who would step up and take his job.
 
Poohgirl may have meant Creole, not Cajun.

RE: "A Chocolate City";
Dark, Milk or White Chocolate??

Almond Joy.
Because...Sometimes you feel like a nut.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom