Is increasing the size of the military a good idea?

TheDoctor

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jun 26, 2006
Messages
3,307
bush has asked Sec. of Defense Gates to look into expanding the size of the military and in particular expanding the size of the Marines and the Army. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11442716/
WASHINGTON - President Bush said on Wednesday he was weighing a short-term increase in U.S. troops in Iraq and believed that the United States should expand its Army and Marine Corps in the long term.

"I’m inclined to believe that we need to increase the permanent size of both the United States Army and the United States Marines,” Bush said at a news conference.
From all accounts that I have seen the prolong conflict in Iraq has weakened or broke our military and so something needs to be done. However, I am curious why bush thinks that it is a good idea now to increase the size of the military when bush attacked Senator Kerry for proposing the same thing two years ago? http://thinkprogress.org/2006/12/20/bush-kerry-troop-increases/
On June 3, 2004, Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) — campaigning for the presidency — proposed expanding the Army by 40,000 troops. Bush quickly slammed the proposal as unnecessary and counter-productive:
Bush’s campaign manager, Ken Mehlman, said Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld already has authorized 30,000 more troops through extended tours and new recruitment. He said the country would be “less safe” under Kerry’s approach.​
In a news release, Kerry explained the problem with the Bush approach:
The Bush administration is relying on temporary solutions including “Stop Loss” orders, recalling the Individual Ready Reserve and extending tours to meet our commitments. These temporary measures have increased the burden on our troops and their families without addressing the underlying reality: we need more troops.​
As recently as six months ago, President Bush was sticking to his guns. From a June 14, 2006, “Statement of Administration Policy“:
The Administration opposes increases in minimum active Army and Marine Corps end strengths in Title IV, because they could require DoD to maintain a higher personnel level than is needed. The restructuring of the Army and the Marine Corps, plus other initiatives, is enabling our military to get more warfighting capability from current end strength.​
This “restructuring” was a central part of Rumsfeld’s efforts to make the military a “more modern force.” Bush cited those efforts as a key reason why he believed Rumsfeld was “one of the finest defense secretaries” in history.
Again, this was a bad idea when Senator Kerry proposed it but is okay now. Or more appropriatedly, bush was against increasing the size of the military before he was for it.
 
Once again Bush needs to step aside and let
leaders decide what is best for the Iraqi situation.


BAGHDAD, Iraq - Defense Secretary Robert Gates found American commanders wary of a proposal to rush more U.S. troops to Iraq as he visited the war-ravaged country Wednesday.

President Bush is considering that idea and others in his search for a fresh path in a 3 1/2-plus year war that has no end in sight and has lost the support of the American public.

On just his third day in charge of the Pentagon, Gates made the unannounced trip with the administration under intense pressure to forge a new strategy — and just hours after the president conceded, for the first time, that the U.S. is not winning the conflict.

After meeting with top U.S. generals at Camp Victory, Gates acknowledged concerns that rushing thousands more American troops to the battlefront could allow the Iraqis to slow their effort take control of the country. He said no decisions have been made.

"It's clearly a consideration," Gates said of how an infusion of American troops might affect Iraqi leaders. "I think that the commanders out here have expressed a concern about that."

Gen. George Casey, the top U.S. commander in Iraq and one of several generals who met with Gates, said he supports boosting troop levels only when there is a specific purpose for their deployment. Other military leaders have expressed uncertainty over the purpose and results of injecting more troops.

more at
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061220/ap_on_re_mi_ea/gates_iraq
 
Now, now, Doctor, the appropriate Washington, DC "thinktank" - approved term that you are looking for is ....... "surge".

Apparently that's all anybody who is anybody is talking about these days.

But seriously, although I was opposed to the war from the start, not going in with enough troops was idiotic. Generals that told Rumsfeld and Bush that we needed more troops were either fired, or ostracized. Kerry was blasted in 2004 for saying we needed more troops. But now, who knows? Do more troops mean more targets for insurgents? Do more troops mean a longer entanglement in Iraq? Will more troops help?

I did hear a bit on the news this morning that Baghdad is a city of 8 million people. Adding however many troops they're talking about, according to the military spokesman they were interviewing, was not going to make a whole lot of difference.
 
I like this idea, IF we are able to do so without weakening ourselves. I'm hoping if we can do so, we can bring this thing to a quick (relative) end & get our troops out of there.
 
Florida_Mom said:
Now, now, Doctor, the appropriate Washington, DC "thinktank" - approved term that you are looking for is ....... "surge".

Apparently that's all anybody who is anybody is talking about these days..
Actually there are two separate proposals One is for an immediate surge or short term increase in the troops in Iraq. This would be done by increasing the tours of the troops already there and accelerating the assignment of troops scheduled to be stationed in Iraq. Such a surge is opposed by the Joint Chiefs of Staff and there is another thread on it. http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?p=16046134#post16046134

Separate from the concept of a surge is the concept that we need to increase the overall size of our military on a long term basis. Rumsfeld was against this concept and Senator Kerry was attacked back in 2004 for proposing an increase in the overall size of our military.
 
Why did Rumsfeld always push for a smaller military in Iraq, anyway? I kept hearing him in interviews saying we needed a "smaller, more agile" operation that would be responsive and easy to move. But, clearly, when that isn't working, why not adjust?
 
Florida_Mom said:
Why did Rumsfeld always push for a smaller military in Iraq, anyway? I kept hearing him in interviews saying we needed a "smaller, more agile" operation that would be responsive and easy to move. But, clearly, when that isn't working, why not adjust?
Rumsfailed worked for the regime
that chanted "Stay the Course" :teeth:
 
I think increasing our military is a good idea...however increase the overall level....NOT the level in Iraq.

We need to bring our troops home from there....now.
 
As a military wife, I see how Clinton's cutting the military size down has effected how hard & long they work. I too support increasing the overall military size.

DH has been too stressed out too long at work from all the special projects created since 9/11...and just when they get started on another, someone working on it gets deployed. I hear about it almost daily from him.

People retire. And recruitment is down. They need more people.
 
Florida_Mom said:
Why did Rumsfeld always push for a smaller military in Iraq, anyway? I kept hearing him in interviews saying we needed a "smaller, more agile" operation that would be responsive and easy to move. But, clearly, when that isn't working, why not adjust?

He was trying to convince Americans that the U.S. military would be able to do the job with our technologically advanced machines of warfare...in other words, it was a win-win politically. Less troops/more $$$ to defense contractors. But they made no contingency plans and became way too inflexible. The insurgency adapted to the war machine, while the U.S. "stayed the course."
 
I think that before the dust settles we will need a much larger military force in general. Iraq isn't the real need for more military, other hot spots around the world have the potential for spreading us way too thin.

As much as we may try to stay out of further involvement, there are just too many things going on around the world to avoid them all. This will probably end up a multi-front war, possibly moreso than World War II. It has nothing to do with Bush or any other past or future leader of our country. It comes more under the heading of stuff happens and it sucks to be us.

It's going to be interesting how a possible draft might play into this. The experts do not recommend drafting, and I tend to agree with them on many points. I just don't know how they will increase our forces without it.
 
SplshMtn99 said:
As a military wife, I see how Clinton's cutting the military size down has effected how hard & long they work. I too support increasing the overall military size.

DH has been too stressed out too long at work from all the special projects created since 9/11...and just when they get started on another, someone working on it gets deployed. I hear about it almost daily from him.

People retire. And recruitment is down. They need more people.


It was the senior George Bush that started the military cuts..He proposed cutting the military by 25 %. Those cuts continued under Clinton...Also the first BRAC's, Base Realignment and closure acts started under Reagan and continued on with Bush then Clinton.
I was on Active Duty from 88 to 91, Under Reagan and Bush..Military bases all over Ca were in the process of closing..El Toro, Mirimar etc,all started their closures during those administration.. The closures were completed early in Clintons presedency but started much earlier than that. I'm not saying Clinton didn't make cuts..He did,but so did the Reagan/Bush administrations
 
JennyMominRI said:
It was the senior George Bush that started the military cuts..He proposed cutting the military by 25 %. Those cuts continued under Clinton...Also the first BRAC's, Base Realignment and closure acts started under Reagan and continued on with Bush then Clinton.
I was on Active Duty from 88 to 91, Under Reagan and Bush..Military bases all over Ca were in the process of closing..El Toro, Mirimar etc,all started their closures during those administration.. The closures were completed early in Clintons presedency but started much earlier than that. I'm not saying Clinton didn't make cuts..He did,but so did the Reagan/Bush administrations

You're right. I didn't mean just Clinton. Regardless of who made the cuts, they cut it too much. They need more people.
 
I think we've really been stretched thin with the conflict/war in Afghanistan and the conflict/war in Iraq. I want all of our troops home from Iraq now but I know that isn't going to happen. So I say, increase the number of troops -- go BIG and get the job done already. It's very distressing to me that we have sent soldiers to war without sufficient equipment/supplies and without sufficient numbers to back them up. I don't want anymore soldiers to die there, but for God sakes give them the numbers they need to quell the uprisings or get them out of there now!!
 
SplshMtn99 said:
You're right. I didn't mean just Clinton. Regardless of who made the cuts, they cut it too much. They need more people.
Thanks for taking that the way it's intended :goodvibes

I think a lot of people just assume all of these cuts came under Democrats only....It's just that with the end of the cold war,it seemed like a reduction was the thing to do.

This is from a book review by the Naval War College
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0JIW/is_1_55/ai_87146688

Although many equate the initiation of personnel and force structure reductions with the end of the Cold War in 1989 or the breakup of the Soviet Union in 1991, DOD, as a whole, started downsizing in 1988. The Army and Air Force started trimming forces in 1987 and the Marine Corps followed suit the following year. The Navy did not start reducing numbers until 1990"; "For the most part, it seems though DOD has managed to keep the cream of the crop in a smaller labor pool. . . . [T]he quality of the Army officer contingent, already high, has been improved by the SSB and VSI initiatives, as most of the commissioned soldiers accepting the bonuses were from the bottom third of their year-groups"; "Some were concerned that African-Americans, as well as other minorities, might bear a disproportionate share of military personnel cuts, but that has not transpired. Along the same line, opportunities for women in the armed forces have not been put on hold because of the downsizing. In fact, their representation has reached record levels"; "Local communities have been hurt by the reduction in the number of DOD installations that started in 1988. However, in many cases, that damages have been significantly less than originally estim ated. Thanks to a higher percentage of personnel cuts than base closures, the infrastructure of our fighting establishment is now even more out of sync with force structure than it was in 1987."

Other conclusions address the need for increased modernization funding, force hollowness (although not on the scale seen in the 1970s), and reductions in personnel and funding (unaccompanied by reductions in global security commitments).

The author (a former Air Force officer of thirteen years' service) has consulted hundreds of sources for his book. The bibliography is sixteen pages long. The numbers and statistics are interesting individually, though their sheer volume is overwhelming. The appendices are simple graphs showing a downward trend from 1987 to 1998. What is missing are conclusions and projections (beyond those contained in the Quadrennial Defense Review) about the implications. Implosion does a credible job of describing, with key statistics and simple explanations, the magnitude and process of the downsizing of the military (the active components were reduced 35.3 percent between 1987 and 1998), but Brasher seems too enamored of statistical pronouncements, leaving the reader waiting for an answer to the question "What does it all mean?" What will this massive force and budgetary reduction mean for the future of the United States military and its role on the international stage
 
tinaluis said:
I think we've really been stretched thin with the conflict/war in Afghanistan and the conflict/war in Iraq. I want all of our troops home from Iraq now but I know that isn't going to happen. So I say, increase the number of troops -- go BIG and get the job done already. It's very distressing to me that we have sent soldiers to war without sufficient equipment/supplies and without sufficient numbers to back them up. I don't want anymore soldiers to die there, but for God sakes give them the numbers they need to quell the uprisings or get them out of there now!!

I feel very similarly, and would support short term military increases (I'd have to be convinced about long term increases, and find Bush's flip-flop on the issue quite interesting).
 
Remember what Teddy said?

Walk softly and carry a big stick.
 
Soubrette said:
I feel very similarly, and would support short term military increases (I'd have to be convinced about long term increases, and find Bush's flip-flop on the issue quite interesting).

Flip-flop? George W. Bush flip-flopped? You can't be serious. ;) The man whose entire campaign in 2004 was framed around Senator Kerry being one of those awful creatures - a flip-flopper. Seriously, I didn't know George Bush was capable of more than a one note song. You mean he actually changed his mind? Amazing!! :teeth:
 
crazyforgoofy said:
Flip-flop? George W. Bush flip-flopped? You can't be serious. ;) The man whose entire campaign in 2004 was framed around Senator Kerry being one of those awful creatures - a flip-flopper. Seriously, I didn't know George Bush was capable of more than a one note song. You mean he actually changed his mind? Amazing!! :teeth:

:teeth: Yes, ironic, isn't it. :teeth:
 

New Posts

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom