rlk - you could be describing me! I had a hard time deciding to pull the trigger on our first ABD for the reasons you listed. Another hesitation for me was we are not big Disney people. We've taken the kids to the parks over the years and enjoyed them just fine, but a mouse-themed vacation would definitely not be our style. So I was a little worried about that part. However, I really wanted to do Alaska without worrying about the logistics myself. We pulled the trigger on that one, and now I swear I can't go back.
First, I had no idea how much energy I was spending on our family trips on logistics. How to get places, what kind of transportation, where/when to eat, how much time to do things - I've never minded this planning at all, but when someone else did it for me - whoa. It was SO much more relaxing.
Second, I didn't realize how much energy my husband and I spend cajoling children to be where they needed to be, when they needed to be there (and yes boys, with your clothes and shoes on). And they are good travelers! But the dynamic on the ABD was completely different - if the guide said to be on the bus at 8:00am, they hopped right to it. They really enjoyed being with other kids and as a result there was just about zero of the low-level bickering that sometimes goes on during family vacations.
Finally, I am an introvert, and one of my kids definitely is. I had a freakout moment on our plane on the way to Alaska when there were 2 other families on our flight, and it suddenly occurred to me I was going to have to actually talk to people and interact with them!! On my vacation!! What?!?! But there is enough down time built in that you will have your time away from the group (I even thought a smidgen too much, which surprised me). And the travel time on the bus is a good time to pop on your head phones and listen to a podcast or something if you need quiet time. Also, I found that because my energy wasn't spent on logistics and corralling kids, I had more energy to chat with and enjoy our fellow travelers. For this strong introvert, it was really great.
Overall, it was the most relaxing family trip we've ever done in terms of my own mental energy.
We have ABD Wyoming booked for this summer. ABD is the only company we've used so far, but we are certainly considering Tauck Bridges,
National Geographic, and Austin Adventures, in addition to ABD, for 2018.