For my family, it was the highlight of the trip. My DH could watch Illuminations every night of the week and never get bored with it though. Honestly, the only other spot that has a better view is from a patio table at the Rose & Crown.
The smoke seemed to dissipate pretty quickly, but I don't have any idea of what the chances are that it would be blowing in the direction of the boats. They are sort of in a cove area and I think would be more protected from it. This is something that we would definitely do again.
Tammi