If YOU were a lawyer, could YOU represent Saddam?

Papa Deuce

<font color="red">BBQ loving, fantasy football pla
Joined
Sep 29, 2003
Messages
17,786
Just curious. I could not. Let someone else defend his "rights".

EDIT: I am not asking whether his rights should be defended. Just whether you could be the person to do it.
 
Of course he doesn't deserve it, but if we didn't allow him to defend his "rights", we'd simply be stooping to his level.
 
cadburysmom said:
Of course he doesn't deserve it, but if we didn't allow him to defend his "rights", we'd simply be stooping to his level.

Right. But could YOU be the one to do it?
 
No..not me.

An interesting aside. I have a friend who is very religious. Almost extreme. She was dating a DEFENSE attorney. I coule never do that. I could not date someone who I knew was probably helping a guilty criminal back on the street.
 

Yes. Everyone deserves the right to have their side of the story told, whether they are guilty or innocent.
 
no, never, and i think saddam should be slowly executed by pulling him apart piece by piece.....
 
If I were a defense attorney, yes. But with a caveat. I would be there only to be sure that his right to a fair trial wasn't violated. I wouldn't try to mount a defense for his actions, only to work within the confines of the courtroom with the presiding judge to be sure he got a fair trial.

I believe that he's a megalomaniac and a sociopath, and as such has a mental defect. His cultural norms are very different from those we value in the "free world", and as such, some things that we might find to be terrible actions are perfectly acceptable under the laws of his country.

Although I believe that he knew right from wrong, and could anticipate the consequences of his actions, I believe that in his mind what he did was perfectly acceptable and legal.

Although the emotional side of me thinks he should be tossed out into a public square in Iraq and let the citizens of that area do what they will with him (likely death by stoning), the logical side of me feels that he is entitled to a fair trial, and that his punishment needs to be determined by a judge if he is found guilty. To do otherwise would simply make him a martyr in his cause.

Anne
 
We once had a well-known defense attorney come speak at our college. He was asked how he could stand to defend criminals with the chance that someone guilty might get off. He explained that his job was to place the burden of proof on the prosecutor and not to get guilty people "off". His goal was to bring up everything that could cause reasonable doubt on the part of the jurors and give the prosecutor the chance to deal with those items.

That was an interesting way to look at it IMO and made me feel a bit better about defense attorneys.
 
when I was a newly-minted attorney, right out of law school and very idealistic, I had an interview with legal aid. the interviewer told me "99% of our clients are guilty. most of them also have a drug dependency, or a family situation, or a psychiatric issue. our job is to get them into a program to treat the underlying problem..."

I never went back for a second interview.

so the answer is -- I AM a lawyer, I firmly believe in justice and the judicial system, and that everyone deserves his day in court and his right to counsel. but no, I couldn't represent Saddam.
 
No I couldn't represent him or anyone who hurts a child. I don't think I could contain myself against those kinds of monstors.

I guess that's why I'm not a lawyer.
 
ducklite said:
If I were a defense attorney, yes. But with a caveat. I would be there only to be sure that his right to a fair trial wasn't violated. I wouldn't try to mount a defense for his actions, only to work within the confines of the courtroom with the presiding judge to be sure he got a fair trial.

I believe that he's a megalomaniac and a sociopath, and as such has a mental defect. His cultural norms are very different from those we value in the "free world", and as such, some things that we might find to be terrible actions are perfectly acceptable under the laws of his country.

Although I believe that he knew right from wrong, and could anticipate the consequences of his actions, I believe that in his mind what he did was perfectly acceptable and legal.

Although the emotional side of me thinks he should be tossed out into a public square in Iraq and let the citizens of that area do what they will with him (likely death by stoning), the logical side of me feels that he is entitled to a fair trial, and that his punishment needs to be determined by a judge if he is found guilty. To do otherwise would simply make him a martyr in his cause.

Anne

well, it's a good thing you are not an attonrey, then...I'm not sure what you mean by I wouldn't try to mount a defense for his actions, only to work within the confines of the courtroom with the presiding judge to be sure he got a fair trial. but it sounds to me like your plan would violate your ethical obligations as an attorney. there can be no "fair trial" unless you mount a defense.
 
Lessa of Pern said:
well, it's a good thing you are not an attonrey, then...I'm not sure what you mean by I wouldn't try to mount a defense for his actions, only to work within the confines of the courtroom with the presiding judge to be sure he got a fair trial. but it sounds to me like your plan would violate your ethical obligations as an attorney. there can be no "fair trial" unless you mount a defense.

I'm not an attorney, and I didn't even sleep in a Holiday Inn last night. :)

I guess I'd make a lousy defense attorney then ;)

Anne
 
i would...for the sake of seeing his side and finding out what went on in that head of his. I'd also like the challenge of it all.
 
If I were the devil herself, I wouldn't represent him.
 
I could not do it. I would have to be a prosecuting attorney, I could not be a defense attorney....thankfully there are others who can do it as people have the right to representation.
 
No way, not me.

I agree that he has the right to a defense, but part of me also thinks that since he took away the rights of so many people, does he actually deserve to have his rights respected? I don't think he deserves it, but I also disagree with taking away anyone's rights.

So, someone should defend him, but I could never do it.

Or maybe he should just try to defend himself. You know what they say about an attorney that has himself for a client . . .
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom