We changed our minds after staying there. (At this point, I've stayed in every
DVC on property and every room at RR except the grand villa.)
We don't love over-the-top theming so we appreciate the subtle inclusion of Disney IP at RR. We like the above average take out and the easy access to CB's takeout. We love a casual meal in Bar Riva too (haven't eaten at Topolinos). We also think Sebastians is surprisingly good.
We like the casual evening vibe around the pools at night. We like the central location. We like that the busses aren't overly crowded. And we love the skyliner (a big surprise to us as well).
I agree there's an increasing problem with the feature pool. We saw families walking over in large groups from CB and waiting for people to open the gate so they could enter. I imagine this will get worse with the CB pool under refurbishment.
I don't understand the objection to the lobby ... doesn't Boardwalk have the same size lobby and everyone seems to love that resort? The lobby at BC is beautiful, but to my mind not very practical ... I hate having to walk through the large lobby coming from the pool or gym. Different strokes I guess.
Overall, I love the quiet vibe and 'easiness' of staying at RR ... easy to grab food or a coffee, easy to grab a bus or skyliner, easy to talk to someone at the front desk if needed, easy to find a place to sit outside and enjoy the nice weather, easy to get what you need without going outside in bad weather, etc. My two complaints would be the occasional confusion about busses when the skyliner is down and non-RR guests using the feature pool since it's too small to accommodate them.
I get it if people don't like it though. Some like a busier place. Some like to be closer to the action. My in-laws like 'condo' type places like SSR/OKW best. We thought we'd love Poly but decided we didn't after staying there last summer. We're going back to BLT this summer since we thought Poly was a nice place to visit but not to stay (for us). S'all good.