If you had to eliminate one, which? Why?

[summermac]

Whispering Canyon Cafe
Coral Reef
Tusker House (breakfast)

ADRs are giving me a serious headache right now.

The others we want are:
50s PTC (dinner)
Crystal Palace (breakfast)
LeCellier (lunch, dinner, whatever we can get)
1900 PF (dinner)
Ohana (dinner)

 

[HG_MOM]

Personally...Coral Reef. I know it is a crowd favourite, but DH and I were not impressed on out last trip. I actually felt sick after we ate.
Just my 2 cents!! Good luck...ADR's are such hard decisions to make!!

 

[summermac]

I was looking over the Coral Reef menu and I wasn't really impressed with it. So that might be it.

I'm having issues with using DDP for two breakfasts. LOL! Tusker House dinner won't fly for us - choices seem a little out there.

 

[septbaby]

Whispering Canyon holds zero interest or enticement for me, so easy choice.

We really liked our lunch at Coral Reef. We ate everything they put in front of us, enjoyed the tank and because it was "underwater" we had no clue of the rain storm going on outside while we ate. It was a great break from the park.

We have not had TH Breakfast. I recently had bfast at Boma and loved that. I understand there are some similarities so I'm sure we'd like that too.

 

[annie1995]

I would go for Whispering Canyon. We all loved Coral Reef, and Tusker House is on our must do list too.

 

[chocolateMinnie]

Personally I would dump 1900PF - never had a meal as bad in my 40years. Ate there twice and both times was appalling, only went back for characters and to see if it was improved by not at all.

WCC is nothing amazing but we found the food to be well cooked and my kids love basic American food.

 

[KatMark]

Whispering Canyon Cafe. It was the worse meal of our trip in September--the service was awful, the food was mediocre at best (DH got sick on the skillet) and there was close to nil on the antics every one talked about (maybe it depends on what night of the week you go).

 

[summermac]

Ahhh - it's just about a tie right now.

 

[septbaby]

Alright I'm obviously still half asleep. Never even noticed your "kidlet info". Now I really say skip WCC. Take your kids to see the "fishies" and the characters. A complete no brainer. They'll get to see the grown ups get scolded at 50's so that will be a similar kind of fun as at WCC.

 

[Quacktatty]

1900 PF - haven't heard much if anything good about that one

 

[eas423]

Personally I would dump 1900PF - never had a meal as bad in my 40years. Ate there twice and both times was appalling, only went back for characters and to see if it was improved by not at all.

This is the consensus I've always heard for 1900 PF dinner, and my best friend confirmed it last year when they booked it for their daughter's birthday. It was terrible.

 

[catne]

I was looking over the Coral Reef menu and I wasn't really impressed with it. So that might be it.

I'm having issues with using DDP for two breakfasts. LOL! Tusker House dinner won't fly for us - choices seem a little out there.

Don't let the menu at Tusker fool you -- Tusker House is mostly plain old Disney buffet food...there are a few "ethnic" foods sprinkled throughout the buffet, but by & large, it's standard Disney buffet food. It is not like Boma at all -- not even in the same category I don't think. Boma is mostly African with a little Disney Buffet sprinkled in. We have been to Boma (did not like it -- spices were way too unusual for us) and Tusker House is not like Boma. Tusker was just perfect for us...the little bit of spicey foods was nice to try, but we mostly ate the usual buffet foods. Good service and bar beverages including nice beer choices too. Delicious dessert buffet.

 

[dawnbu40]

We weren't impressed with Coral Reef. DD loves seafood and after we ate there she didn't feel well all day. We like the rest of your selections though!

 

[disneystacy]

I would get rid of Coral Reef or 1900 Park Fare. Both are not good imo.

 

[Pakey]

My least favorite is Whispering Canyon. It's on my very short list of never to return to (two bad visits means it goes on the short list).

 

[summermac]

DH was just looking @ menus with me and he likes WCC over Coral Reef too. Hope I'm not making a mistake. I've never eaten at either so I guess I won't know if I did or not. LOL!

 

[MickeyMomOfThree]

No help here, offering different advise, but WCC is one of our never miss places. We love the food and the antics, my kids would hate it if we skipped it. We have always enjoyed CR, but don't consider it a can't miss and go every other or every third trip, never been to Tusker House, but enjoyed the old Breakfastasarus. I hear it is similar. Good Luck!!!

 

[Paging Tom Morrow]

Coral Reef. Something about eating fish while viewing it's cousin doesn't appeal to me.

 

[hugabearjo]

I have to agree, 1900 park fare was bad enough in sept. to be on my never return list. I really enjoy coral reef, WCC is okay but I would cut it over coral reef any day. I have never eaten at tusker house so I can't comment there.

I don't know that you can go wrong though after all you are at disney

 

[shellybaxter]

I would dump Coral Reef. I don't like the menu. I very much enjoyed dinner at 1900 in December