I really want to know!!! Cancel your cruise because of the new policy.

Would you cancel a DCL cruise because of the new Alcohol carry on policy?

  • I have/will cancel my cruise vacation because of the new policy.

    Votes: 26 10.1%
  • I will not cancel my cruise vacation because of the new policy.

    Votes: 108 41.9%
  • No big deal to me, I don't drink.

    Votes: 49 19.0%
  • I drink but don't bring alcohol on board.

    Votes: 75 29.1%

  • Total voters
    258
It is posts like these that are only trying to fan the flames, and they have been on the other threads too. They are not adding to the discussion, just posting an opinion to draw a reaction from others.

Wow. I can't believe what I am reading...

I only posted a hypothesis about what could be the reasons why some people would not agree with the new policy. FYI. I have never seen being a "cheapskate" as a bad thing.

I take great offense of you categorizing me as a troll (because this is basically what you are doing right now).
 
Yeah. One of those too. But we are getting ready to close it for the season...and it is over 90 today! But when the leaves and pine needles start to fall, there is nothing else to do. But I am going to sit back by the pool with a nice bottle of Rose' after I finish baking the season's first apple pie!

Should open up a bottle of Rosa Regale:) We found this in the concierge lounge on the Fantasy and really liked it, but we're really bummed when we got home and found out it was 20 a bottle. This is now our very special occasion drink:)
 
Wow. I can't believe what I am reading...

I only posted a hypothesis about what could be the reasons why some people would not agree with the new policy. FYI. I have never seen being a "cheapskate" as a bad thing.

I take great offense of you categorizing me as a troll (because this is basically what you are doing right now).
The person wanted some examples so I just multi quoted, I guess I shouldn't have bit on it, but I did. We are very frugal/cheapskates and love what it allows us to do.

Guess this comes down to some days you are the bug and the windshield and today I have been a little of both.
 
I did not mean you were being a troll but accusing me of being one (Considering the description that is usually applied to "trolls" which is posting stuff to create reactions).
 

I have read The Great Gatsby, since it was written by Fitzgerald about the place I live and where he lived while writing it. The house he lived in is about 5 minutes away from where I am. As for being contemptuous to other posters, not everybody travels to Europe and has the same experiences you have had. I didn't see people bringing their own bottles, but I wasn't looking when I was in Europe. People are disappointed by this policy and need to vent, I am not since I don't drink a lot and I have never brought alcohol on the ship. I have brought ginger ale on because I was on the WBPC in May 14, I wanted it because I had found out how settling the stomach it was if I felt queasy.
I think it is pretty obvious from my other posts about running around in my underwear, surviving only on pine cones and squirrel droppings, and hosting hookah parties in my stateroom that I have an absurd sense of humor and am rarely expressing deep concern for the topic. Despite my love of literature AND pearl clutching I was being my usual absurd self. If I need to kick it up a notch I certainly accept the challenge.
 
I think it is pretty obvious from my other posts about running around in my underwear, surviving only on pine cones and squirrel droppings, and hosting hookah parties in my stateroom that I have an absurd sense of humor and am rarely expressing deep concern for the topic. Despite my love of literature AND pearl clutching I was being my usual absurd self. If I need to kick it up a notch I certainly accept the challenge.
Also, everything I know about the world and its finer pleasures I got from watching British comedies in the 1970's and 1980's. Like all civilized geeks.
 
I only posted a hypothesis about what could be the reasons why some people would not agree with the new policy.
Well, perhaps it was a poor choice of words, because:
In the end, it could only be a matter of money because there are drinks and glasses and bottles of wine available everywhere on that boat!
does not read like a "hypothesis" and instead reads much more like a conclusion. "In the end, it could only be a matter of money" can't be interpreted any other way except as your conclusion that people who bring their own beverages on board are doing so only to save money and not because the ship does not carry their preferred selection. And this is a rather ironic conclusion given that these penny pinchers are sailing on the single most expensive cruise line in its class. Again, given your post above, I take it that you didn't really mean what you posted earlier. But you have to admit that it certainly came off that way.
 
/
Well, perhaps it was a poor choice of words, because:

does not read like a "hypothesis" and instead reads much more like a conclusion. "In the end, it could only be a matter of money" can't be interpreted any other way except as your conclusion that people who bring their own beverages on board are doing so only to save money and not because the ship does not carry their preferred selection. And this is a rather ironic conclusion given that these penny pinchers are sailing on the single most expensive cruise line in its class. Again, given your post above, I take it that you didn't really mean what you posted earlier. But you have to admit that it certainly came off that way.

I'll blame my "poor choice of words" on the fact that I am french canadian and I'm doing the best that I can when I'm trying to express hypothesis/opinions/point of view in a language that is not my "mother tongue". Nuance can be lost in translation.
 
There are people who spend $400 on a pair of athletic shoes that will never hit a court. I have no judgement. You collect your dreamy wine. You deserve it. If we cross paths, I'd love a sip of a Barolo. Just love them.
Exactly. Lots of people (probably most people on the Board) have something to which they devote what seems to be a disproportionate amount of their disposable income. Time pieces. Cars. Disney cruises. Bicycles. Firearms. And the list goes on. They are not psychotic any more than I am an alcoholic.

And yes, of course you can share in my wine when we cross paths. And the ironic thing is, most of the people in this thread who are critical about bringing wine on board would make overt hints about wanting to taste the bottle that we brought to the table when they see the sommelier decanting it. They might be dubious now. But they'd make no secret about the fact that they would love to push their Woodbridge off to the side for a moment. It happens all the time.
 
Lots of people (probably most people on the Board) have something to which they devote what seems to be a disproportionate amount of their disposable income. Time pieces. Cars. Disney cruises. Bicycles. Firearms. And the list goes on.

In our case...children. All we have left is a 9, 16 and a 17 year old. It's getting closer and closer to just one. (:
 
Interesting that in this and other threads, some still feel as though the ones with issues with the policy change are upset because we can't get blackout drunk.
 
Last edited:
If you don't want controversy, don't ask a controversial question. Stated another way, don't ask a question if you aren't prepared to receive an answer.

Or answers that you do not agree with. If you state your opinion on any subject, be prepared for others to have opinions that differ from yours. Be respectful of others opinions and do not read into them. If a person says that they can have fun without drinking, then they are not necessarily being judgmental about those who do. If a person says that they are considering leaving DCL because of the change in the alcohol problem, they have every right to do so. Do not imply that they have problems because they wish to have adult beverages.

I almost never drink alcohol, so the policy change does not affect me. But if I did enjoy adult beverages, I can see how the policy change affects those that do enjoy them.

My point to all this is that everyone should have thicker skins and stop getting so upset with other people's posts. Do not read into them. Unless a person explicitly insults another poster, then just respect their opinion and stop fanning the flames.
 
Oh, I totally disagree. I strip down to my bra and a thong the minute I get on board. I have one of those camel things filled with Sprite and a liter of cheap vodka and I just start running around like a total maniac until I hear the Single Ladies song 'cause THAT'S MY JAM! I'll spend a few minutes grinding on complete strangers and racing around avoiding capture by my husband and the Disney Bummer Patrol. Then I'll take a nap until dinner.
Class act I see...bwaha
 
It is posts like these that are only trying to fan the flames, and they have been on the other threads too. They are not adding to the discussion, just posting an opinion to draw a reaction from others.

Well here is my opinion, we are truly looking at moving on from DCL due to, the diminishing benifits for the loyalty program, for example dropping the extra OBC for this group, only getting the onboard booking credit on one cruise, same itineraries, same shows and acts over and over (John Charles is only one with unique shows), service and friendliness of staff is not the same as prior years, pool hours being shorter (was nice when they were open when we skipped a show), many of the menus haven't changed much since we started cruising DCL, and research we have done has shown that DCL is falling more in line with other cruise lines as far as what they offer. One big annoyance was the last cruise we were on we stayed onboard during port days that we had already stopped at on previous cruises hoping to ride the aquadunk like I had on previous port days and it was closed until the ship left port this last time:(.

The alcohol policy was the tipping point, because of the way DCL handled it, very arrogantly, them thinking they are heads and tails above everyone still. Before our next DCL cruise we will price out celebrity and princess cruises before we go onboard and if they are cheaper we will give them a go. We may still do a placeholder on DCL in case the other lines don't meet our expectations we can get back on DCL. If we find we really like one of the other lines we would dump the placeholder. It is a case of we don't know what we are missing with other lines until we try them.
Not flaming anything....one word comes to mind as far as this post...DENIAL!
 
Not flaming anything....one word comes to mind as far as this post...DENIAL!
Last post then I am done denial of what lol?

And no denial, we love DCL cruises, looking at other lines was not an easy decision, and who knows we will probably be back on DCL soon enough, but it took all the reasons I posted to get us there
 
Last edited:
To answer the OP's question: The change in the alcohol policy has not affected whether or not I will sail DCL. I don't drink very much to begin with and have never drank on a DCL cruise (pregnant the first time, wanted to keep my full wits with a toddler the second time.) I have stated on other alcohol-related threads that I do find the change disappointing, though, as it seems DCL has been changing several policies recently to detract from rather than add to guests' experiences.

To comment on the thread in general: I am shocked by some of the judgmental, passive-aggressive comments. To imply that someone should sail Carnival if the new policy messes with his or her vacation budget?! Just because someone wants to stick to a budget doesn't mean they can't afford more. I personally don't raid my savings account for vacation purposes. I divide the cost of my vacation budget up per paycheck and pay from my checking account rather than savings. (I also have a separate amount that goes straight into savings each paycheck.) So even though this particular change in policy had no effect on me, if it had affected me, I would be annoyed if I had to dip into my savings account to make up for a change in my budget due to lack of sufficient notice from DCL. With sufficient notice, people can either rebudget or decide if they would like to cancel.

And in terms of comments along the lines of "Glad I don't need alcohol to have fun" or "People have problems if this is a big deal"--some people like to drink and some people don't. Judging those who drink doesn't make you a better person; as long as people aren't getting so drunk that they are interfering with your enjoyment of the cruise, who cares if they have one drink or 1/2 a bottle of wine? I know we can't always control what we judge in our heads, but we can control what we post.
 
Not flaming anything....one word comes to mind as far as this post...DENIAL!

CGolf didn't accuse you of flaming anything. Fanning the flames and flaming are different things. Flaming is insulting someone. Fanning the flames is making a situation worse. Now, one could flame someone in order to fan the flames, but they aren't the same thing.

I read CGolf's comment and then your response to it, including, "DENIAL". One phrase comes to mind as far as your post: It seems as though you either didn't read it or didn't understand it.
 
I didn't vote because none of the answers cover my situation. If it were just my family, I'd be cancelling. Too many recent downgrades by DCL and too many upgrades on other lines for me to consider DCL for future cruises. We generally brought alcohol with us, enjoyed receiving it as FE gifts, etc. but truthfully, never really drank most of it. But it was a perk. Same as the Mickey mail - only on 1 of our 5 cruises so far have we had anything signed. Fresh popcorn as extra cost, change of pre-order water from Evian to Dasani (same price!), more and more extra pay stuff (light up glasses pushed at dinner, pushing of water packages, beer mugs, etc. on embarkation, constant pitches to buy this, or buy that) and top that with the continually rising prices just doesn't make DCL a contender for us any more.

Friends of mine are joining us in November. They have never cruised before and decided on this cruise because we were going. The announcement came just before our PIF date (though we were already PIF due to wanting to check in early when gold members were allowed). Our friends also have non-refundable airfare from Air Canada so cancelling is out.

I won't however be doing an on board booking.

Unless I hear some kind of exciting offer on DCL, I will happily continue to sail Royal, Celebrity and my favourite cruise line Carnival and not consider pricing out any further potential cruises on DCL.
 
I have discovered that I am both an impoverished low-brow drunkard AND, inexplicably, a poncey snooty Eurotrash snob. So, I figure I have come out ahead. Cheers!
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!

























DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top