And why should OP jump ahead of all the other non-AP guests who are locked out of MK?
No one is saying the OP
should. But if they ask and GS happens to have the authority to pull some strings, then luck is just on the side of the OP. It doesn't mean the OP is more special than other guests, it just means they got the right GS agent. GS agents have the discretion to handle situations as they see fit. That's why guest remunerations for bad experiences differ. And to be clear, I'm not saying the OP is owed anything and I wouldn't consider this a poor experience, I'm just using it as an example to support that GS agents can and do things in the name of customer service all the time. If the answer is that GS can't do anything, then OP should be polite about it and move along.
It isn't really poor customer service. This entire issue was due to the guest hedging their bets. They had the same exact opportunity as everyone else. If the CM can't let them into the park, that does not mean Disney or guests services didn't do a good job. Six guests or not, the OP isn't any different than any other random person trying to get into a closed park on that particular day.
It doesn't hurt to ask as long as the OP and others realize that the CM may not make an exception. We've all seen the posts where people go ballistic because they didn't get what they wanted. One person's pixie dust is someone else's entitlement.
Absolutely agree. I think all of us on the opposite side of this have been saying all along that as long as OP realizes they aren't owed anything and that the answer may very well be no, then there is no harm at all in calling.
I just disagree that it's appropriate to recommend someone call and ask GS for special treatment, when everyone else who might need park passes or who might want to change them but can't is in the same boat.
But those people have the same exact opportunity as OP to call.
The problem is, Disney can't allow everyone who wants to do those things to do them, because in the aggregate it would be highly disruptive--just like if everyone was allowed to change park passes by "just asking" it would be unworkable.
I don't disagree that Disney can't appease everyone, but considering we know for fact that they can and do pull strings in some circumstances (i.e. ROTR boarding groups), then why wouldn't someone simply call and ask?
And these days if someone gets away with some special exception and says so on the internet, everyone starts demanding it.
That sounds like a them problem. If people aren't astute enough to realize that customer service scenarios are often handled on a case by case basis and there isn't a blanket resolution for all people and all problems, then that's on them. Its not something OP or me or anyone else should be concerned with.
GS is not going to help OP get passes that are sold out for all the reasons I've been explaining, so it is a waste of OP's time.
That may very likely be the case. But respectfully, I'm still not understanding why you're so fiercely against OP making the call when it doesn't affect you in the slightest. Even if OP calls knowing for 99% certain that GS can't get passes for them, at the very least maybe GS can tell OP when they expect another drop, or when other people have had success finding canceled passes, or whatever.