I would also definitely suggest staying at the All Stars - the convenience of being on site with kids is wonderful! Especially with the age difference in your children - if you need to go back to the hotel for a nap with the babies, DH could stay at the park with the older ones. All you have to do is hop on a bus. I have three girls, but a nine year age difference with the 2nd and 3rd. I used to bring my little one back to the hotel and get her settled for the nap, then DH and older two girls would come back, rest up and we usually all headed out for a swim.
We also usually drive too, because airfare usually costs at least $700 for the five of us, and we can drive it for about $100. We bring an ice chest with some softdrinks in, and we always bring some snacks - chips, candy, etc. One year, I thought I'd be a great mom and bring fruit for us along the way. I cut up cantlaloup, watermelon, grapes, etc. Well, it seemed like we were stopping every five minutes for a potty break!
We also usually eat breakfast in the room - much quicker and cheaper! I bring poptarts, breakfast bars, instant grits (or oatmeal) when my little one was younger. I used the hot water from the sink though, that way it was warm enough for her, but not too hot for her to eat. We often came back to the room for our nap/swim break and just ate a snack and drinks. Sometimes, its too hot for a big meal. Also, watch for portions in the Disney restaurants - even the kids meals have larger portions. It can usually be more than enough to share.
Glad to see you were able to get the rooms for an extra night - that day yall spend around the pool will be great - especially in the heat of the summer. As another poster mentioned, check out the petting zoo at Fort Wilderness. Also, they have the Chip and Dale marshmallow roast and movie. The petting zoo is free, as well as the movie. There is a small fee for the marshmallows for roasting. We plan on checking these out for our upcoming trip in October.
Hope yall have a great time - good luck! Be sure to take it easy, and take lots of pictures! I'm sure it'll be a great vacation!!!!