magickingdomprincess
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2015
- Messages
- 1,531
I'm a bit late on this, but I have some thoughts.
I'm also a new owner, just buying in back in March. We haven't even had our first stay yet (that's coming February). We have a small direct contract and a larger resale contract. To me, the reallocation is just part of the deal. I did a lot of research on DVC before we bought in, and one of the things that was constantly reinforced is that reallocations can happen at any time, so always make sure you buy a few more points than you need for your typical reservation to serve as a cushion. That's why I'm a little surprised at the strong reaction everyone is having to this. I get it's a little slimy to not mention anything about the reallocation at the annual meeting when it was clearly already decided though.
I would stay off the DVC board for a while if it's depressing you. You bought in because you thought it was a good idea. You (hopefully) did research before buying - I assume you did because you bought resale and the average person buying DVC direct likely has no idea resale even exists. If DVC was a good idea for you, your family, and your vacation patterns earlier this year, it still is. This reallocation may cost you a few more points when you go back in 2020. Maybe in 2022 there's another reallocation that lowers the points cost to even fewer than it costs now. You just don't know.
The lawsuit thing caught me off guard.
Yes, they mean the direct (from DVC) price per point is increasing. I believe CCV is going up $6/point. Not sure about the other resorts, but really if you're buying any other resort it makes much more sense to go resale. The general advice is, if you can plan your trips 10-11 months in advance, you love WDW, and you know you will go back regularly, DVC might make sense. From there it's direct vs resale - most people can't make use of the savings the Gold AP will offer over the life of the contract compared to the difference in price per point over resale, and it's a perk that could go away at any time. So the only real reason to go direct is if you love CCV (or Riviera, or whatever is currently being sold at the time), and you know you want to stay there for most of your stays.
Otherwise, buy resale, and buy during a recession or during a big sell-off which lowers prices (which, never know, could happen now with all this reallocation stuff).
I agree about the discount should be calculated. My deciding factor in just deciding to buy in was that with my husband who is a bed princess (king bed or his own bed) if we wanted to stay on site we would need minimum two rooms. Cheapest I could get two rooms at a moderate would be around $150 at CBR. I know a lot of you have done the agency deals etc but even with discounts that is still a lot. We were moderate in two rooms or off site. For us going multiple times a year right now and wanting to stay on site DVC made sense. But yes I wish we had bought sooner!
Thanks yes I did a ton of research which is why I bought OKW as direct (like @PolyRob wanted the benefits for as long as they are there) and then found the larger BLT resale. On our May trip we even went to the resorts and talked them into letting us see the rooms. It was not even like I just bought CCV after doing the tour...I got on the waiting list to buy OKW because it worked best for our family. It is definitely the sky is falling mentality on the DVC section where they all keep feeding on each other.
I posted here for a measured outlook. So thank you everyone!
Sorry, not to derail the thread on the DVC points reallocation too much, but I did read a few of the threads last night and I can definitely see how many people are upset. I saw a chart that someone had done comparing the 2019 and 2020 points, and it seemed that almost all of the nights and room types went up, except for the higher point seasons for 2 bedrooms. So for the vast majority of members, the cost per night is going up (myself included). I can see why many are upset. And why not lower 1 bedroom costs when they're the last to book? We don't always stay the same nights or time of year so it's not like I'm directly losing 1 night or anything, but I will definitely feel the effect. Not sure I think a lawsuit is called for or would be successful, but a better explanation of the reasoning would be appreciated. I'm (still) on the WL (supposedly 4th on the list) to add on at BCV, and will probably go forward with the add on, although this is making me think twice.