I'm planning a trip to Tokyo
Disneyland for my 60th in September 2019. The Hilton Tokyo Bay seems like the more reasonable of the options. What would be the best card to get to earn Hilton points? I already have the Southwest visas (plus and premier) to get me to the West Coast from Boston. Then Alaska airlines to get me to Hawaii. DVC points to stay at Aulani. My husband will need a few days to recover from the flights before we fly to Japan. Cash to get me from Honolulu to Tokyo. All suggestions are welcome!
Thanks! I haven't applied for a credit card in over a year, if that is what you mean? I currently have four Chase cards - 2 SW, 1 Disney and 1 Sapphire. I'm looking at the Amex Hilton card with no fee and 75,000 point sign-up bonus but one night at Hilton Tokyo Bay is 117,000 points so probably not the best deal for us - even though I travel for work, sometimes, we have to use the University's travel card not any of our own.
So a couple of things to help us get a better idea of how to help.
Is your husband willing to apply for credit cards too, or would he be okay if you applied for credit cards in his name? This is what we refer to as “2-Player mode.” Two partners signing up for credit cards allows the couple to double up on the signup bonuses, potentially have one get a card first then refer the other to that card for the referral bonus, and allows each player to alternate card openings and slow their pace of signups so neither comes off hitting an issuer too hard and appearing as a credit risk to the banks.
How many credit cards have you opened in the past 24 months? (And if your husband is signing up for cards too, we need to look at this information for him too.) You mentioned you haven’t applied for any credit cards in over a year, but what about the past 2 years? Because while we’re looking at Amex for their Hilton cards, we should also look at Chase, which if you’ve been following has a “5/24 rule” that will deny you their most lucrative rewards cards if your credit report shows you opened 5 or more credit cards in the past 24 months. It would really help us help you if you could list what cards you might’ve opened in the past 24 months, with their name, month/date of opening.
Also, do either you or your husband have a business, or even a side business, and are you open to applying for business credit cards? A side business could be anything from selling things online (eBay,
Amazon, Craigslist, Facebook, etc.), contracting, consulting, tutoring or teaching, babysitting, pet sitting or grooming, driving for Uber/Lyft, photography, renting out real estate, etc. Really anything can be considered a business for the purposes of applying for a business credit card. Business cards have some of the best signup bonuses, and an additional benefit is that most credit card issuers do not report business cards to the credit bureaus, so these cards do not show on your credit report and Chase will not count these against your 5/24 status.
What are your monthly expenses like? In order to earn the signup bonuses, the terms require you to meet a minimum required spend (“MSR”) by charging a certain amount onto the card within a certain amount of time (usually, 3 months). The bigger bonuses usually require a higher amount of spend, $3,000 to $5,000 within 3 months. Even if you don’t typically charge that much to your credit cards each month, if you look at your expenses there are usually things that you're paying cash or check for that you should be charging to a credit card for a small or no fee.
Two things in your plans that caught my eye:
(1) You’re visiting Tokyo Disneyland in September 2019 and are considering the Hilton Tokyo Bay because it seems like the most reasonably priced option.
- How many days are you planning to be in Japan?
- Are you planning to stay in and around Tokyo Disneyland/Tokyo Bay the entire time?
Hilton doesn’t have room availability out for September 2019 yet, but selecting 5 nights randomly in mid-September 2018 (9/16-9/21/18) shows standard award rooms at 75-80k HH points, and 315k HH for all 5 nights.
Checking Chase’s Ultimate Rewards (UR) travel portal on my Chase Sapphire Reserve (which makes my UR points worth 50% more) for the same dates at the Hilton Tokyo Bay, I see standard rooms from 111,740 UR points + taxes and fees. Although I’m not seeing Tokyo Disney’s other hotels on the UR travel portal, Chase’s Cruise & Tour travel agents should be able to book them using UR points, too.
So how do we get the points you need?
As I mentioned, Amex has increased offers right now until 6/27/18 on some of their Hilton cards. These are the highest historical offers on these card, which is something you want to consider when you apply for Amex cards. Amex has a one bonus per product per lifetime rule, which limits you to only one bonus on a card product – you take a lower offer, it’s very unlikely Amex will match you to a higher offer later, and you can’t sign up for the card again for another bonus – so it’s always in your best interest to go for the best and highest offer possible.
- The Amex Hilton Honors Business card (“Hilton Biz”) has a signup offer of 125k HH points after meeting a $5k/3 months MSR. If you and your husband both sign up for this card, that’s at least 250k HH points towards your Tokyo Bay stay. Ideally, in 2-Player mode, one of you would sign up for the Hilton Biz first, then refer the other to the Hilton Biz before the 125k HH points offer expires so Player 1 can earn 125k HH on her card, get a 25k HH referral bonus for referring Player 2, and Player 2 could also earn his own 125k HH, then pool all those HH points together when you’re ready to book. That’s about 285k HH points from just 2 cards (125k HH Player 1 signup bonus + 5k HH from purchases to meet MSR on Card 1 + 25k HH referral bonus + 125k HH Player 2 signup bonus + 5k HH from purchases to meet MSR on Card 2).
Unfortunately, because the increased offer of 125k HH points for the Hilton Biz ends on 6/27/18, it’s unlikely Player 1 will get her card in time to refer Player 2. And because the MSR is relatively high at $5k in 3 months, it may not be practical for 2 partners to be working on a combined $10k MSR in practically the same 3 months period. The previous offer on the Hilton Biz was 100k HH points: 75k HH after $3k in 3 months, and an additional 25k HH after $1k in the first 6 months. Player 1 could still jump on the increased offer of 125k HH points for Card 1, then when you’re ready to take on the MSR on Card 2, refer Player 2 to the Hilton Biz for the 25k HH referral bonus, and Player 2 would probably see a standard 100k HH points signup bonus on Card 2. That’s still about 260k HH points (125k HH Player 1 signup bonus + 5k HH from purchases to meet MSR on Card 1 + 25k HH referral bonus + 100k HH Player 2 signup bonus + 4k HH from purchases to meet MSR on Card 2).
Some of the Hilton Biz perks are pretty good, including complimentary Gold status, 12x bonus points at Hilton hotels and resorts (and 6x bonus points at gas stations, restaurants, and other categories), and a weekend reward night at after $15k spend on the card.
The real upside to the Hilton Biz is that it’s an Amex business card, which does not report to your credit report and won’t add to your 5/24 count if you want to apply for Chase’s cards. As a practical matter, Amex is known to give away their business cards like candy.
- You also mentioned the Hilton Honors no-fee card with a 75k HH points signup bonus with a $1k in 3 months MSR. Although it’s a no fee card with a relatively low MSR, it also doesn’t offer very much because 75k HH points will barely get you 1 night at the Hilton Tokyo Bay. In addition, as a personal Amex card, it will be reported to your credit reports and Chase will count this card against your 5/24 count. On the one hand, it’s a relatively easy way to bag 75k HH points (or 150k HH points between you and your husband) for no fee, but it’s also a small fishy when the ocean is full of bigger catch – like Chase’s cards that offer better rewards
first.
Here are Amex’s four Hilton cards compared:
https://www.doctorofcredit.com/four-american-express-hilton-cards-compared/(This article mentions a $50 statement credit as part of the increased offers on the no fee Hilton Honors and Hilton Biz cards, but be aware that there are reports of a glitch – in trying to trigger the offer with the statement credit for the Hilton Biz, an error on the backend would open a Hilton personal card instead of the Hilton Biz card, which obviously is not the card you might’ve applied for and the personal card counts against your 5/24. We recommend applying directly or through a "support" link to avoid this risk.)
On to Chase –
So let’s say a 5-night stay at the Hilton Tokyo Bay will cost you about 115k UR points. Let’s do a rundown of some of Chase’s Ultimate Rewards cards and their signup (and referral) bonuses:
Chase Sapphire Preferred (“CSP”) – 50k UR signup bonus, 10k UR referral bonus (5k UR bonus for adding an authorized user – but don’t add Player 2!)
Chase Sapphire Reserve (“CSR”) – 50k UR signup bonus, 10k UR referral bonus
Chase Ink Business Preferred (“CIP”) – 80k UR signup bonus, 20k UR referral bonus
Chase Ink Business Cash (“CIC”) – 50k UR signup bonus, no referrals
Chase Ink Business Unlimited (“CIU”) – 50k UR signup bonus, no referrals
Chase also offers the Freedom and Freedom Unlimited personal cards, but although they are solid cards for earning UR points, they don’t have very big signup bonuses so it’s usually recommended to downgrade (“product change”) a Sapphire card to one of the Freedoms, rather than sign up for the Freedom cards outright.
Keep in mind that the above cards are all subject to Chase’s 5/24 rule. You must be under 5/24 to be approved for the Sapphire and Ink cards. However, for Ink cards, since they are business cards, the Ink cards won’t add to your 5//24 count. There are additional rules like the “one Sapphire rule,” which you may be subject to since you hold a Sapphire card, that would prevent you from getting approved for another Sapphire card. There are timing rules too, like how frequently you can apply for Chase’s personal and business cards. Please check in with us to help you formulate a strategy and double check you’re operating within an issuer’s rules.
But as you can see, there are a lot of ways you can open just 2 or 3 Chase cards to get to 115k UR points to cover your Hilton Tokyo Bay stay.
(2) You’re planning to pay cash for airfare from HNL to Tokyo.
Why? You could start by opening up some Chase UR-earning cards (listed above) and use the points you earn on them to either:
- Book flights on the Chase UR portal the same way as if you were paying cash on Expedia (really, the Chase UR travel portal runs on Expedia, and the currency is UR points and cash). 1 UR point is equal to 1 cent if you decide to “cash out” with a statement credit or bank deposit (don’t do this, because UR points are worth more when redeemed for travel). If you have a CSP or CIP, and you’ve pooled all your UR points on either of these cards, then you can redeem your UR points at 1 UR point = 1.25 cents towards travel booked on the UR portal. If you’ve pooled all your UR points onto a CSR, then you can redeem 1 UR point = 1.5 cents towards travel booked on the UR portal. You’re essentially paying the cash fare shown on the travel portal using UR points, which are worth more if your points are held and redeemed on a CSP, CIP, or CSR.
- Or, transfer UR points 1:1 to Chase’s many airline partners, including British Airways and United, which awards programs will get you from HNL to Tokyo.
So which option is better?
(I’m not as familiar with BA, so I’ll use United as an example.)
I see from awardhacker.com that it would cost as little as 27.5k United MileagePlus (“UA”) miles for a one-way economy award ticket from HNL to Tokyo. Keep in mind that Saver award availability is limited, so you should have the points and miles in place far enough in advance to book your award seats.
I checked United.com, and don’t see a 27.5k UA miles Saver award available for our hypothetical departure date of 9/15/18 (it’s at the standard award of 65k UA miles), but there’s Saver award availability on 9/17 and 9/18/18 (but not ideal, with 1 stopover and over 24 hrs. duration!). Looking at the rest of September 2018, I see there’s Saver award availability on 9/25/18 for 27.5k UA miles with no stopovers and a duration of slightly less than 8 hrs. The award price is 27.5k UA miles + $5.60. The cash price of the same flight booked directly with United is $592.40. The cash price of the same flight booked on the UR travel portal is the same $592.40, but because my CSR makes booking with UR points worth 50% more, I’d pay 39,493 UR points (or 47,392 UR points when booking with the CSP or CIP). Since 1 UR point transfers to 1 UA mile, transferring 27,500 UR points to United for 27,500 UA miles to book the Saver award is a better deal and use of your points.
But you need to get those points first!
Let us know what you’d like to do. Several of us are planning trips to Japan in the next year or two.
@calypso726 and I have plotted out hypothetical flights for
@Haley R, who’s working on some Chase business cards right now towards a trip to Japan next spring. And if you’re interested, we’d encourage you to join our community on Reddit, where we have a private group with tips, guides, and links to apply for credit cards that we use to support each other.