Thinking of closing my Disney card any advice on which card to replace it with? I really only use it to pay for gas and some meals. But it's not doing much for me. I have a CFU and CIP but that is pretty much strictly for my business.
I would keep the old Disney card open, and try to use it once a year just to keep it alive. It's better credit-score-wise to keep cards open, for both the credit line available (thus lower utilization), and average age of accounts (especially important if this is one of your older cards). If it's the annual fee (AF) Disney card, you can Product Change (PC) it to the No AF Disney card.
Most of us are here for the Sign Up Bonus (SUB), which outweighs the reward categories. If the card is not valuable after the first year PC it to a no AF card.
Amex Platinum has a 60-125k SUB (worth ~$1,000), 10x bonus on gas, grocery for 6 months, but has a hefty $550 AF, and has nice benefits to make the AF less painful: $200 Uber/Uber Eats credit, $200 air incidental credit, $100 Saks Fifth Ave credit, and several less tangible benefits.
Amex Gold has a 60k SUB (worth ~$600), 4x on dining, takeout, delivery, and grocery, with a $250 AF. Benefits include $120 Cheesecake Factory credit, $100 air incidentals credit. I think this will have a $120 Uber/Uber Eats credit in 2021, and the air incidentals will end in 2021.
Chase Sapphire Preferred has a 60k SUB (worth ~$600), with a $95 AF. You earn 2x on dining and travel. Temporarily you can spend your URs to pay yourself back for grocery purchases at the 25% bonus amount of 1.25x. The 1.25x is standard bonus on portal travel purchases.
Chase Freedom Flex has a $200 SUB with no AF. You earn 5x on grocery, travel, and quarterly rolling categories, and 3x at drug stores (a unique category among cards).
ETA: After you narrow down what you like, let us know and we can provide more details about the card(s). Like the Uber/Uber Eats credits are doled out monthly.
