I don't think her daughter will be going to WDW any time soon...

All I know is that when my DD walked out of the Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique wearing her princess dress and sash, she felt special and loved. I hope she feels like that for the rest of her life. And, no, she doesn't think she is a real princess or that she will ever become one. She is 7 and wants to be a teacher :thumbsup2 princess:
 
Oh geez this article is ridiculous. I think at some time or another all of us dream of being someone else for a day wether it be a queen, a princess, a pirate, a jedi, what have you. Who cares if a young girl wants to have her hair and nails done and feel pretty for a day? No one told her she has to act like a diva.

I wonder how this woman feels about Halloween? We might as well just ban that holiday since it's encouraging children (adults too :P) to stuff themselves full of candy and "be" someone else for an evening. :rotfl2:
 
I've said it once and I'll say it a thousand times, we're in an age of over-analyzation and sensationalism.

We analyze things that don't need analyzing and we sensationalize everything.
 
This is an old arguement. Remember when Barbies came out? (Ok I'm dating myself ;) ) Every one was paranoid that we were giving girls the wrong idea with Barbies perfect figure, waiting for Ken to show up, etc, etc. Little girls love to play dress up, always have.
Personally, I'd rather they try to be princesses than dress up a la Britney spears when they are only 9.
 

I think it's healthy to encourage children's creativity, and dressing up and playing princess seems pretty innocuous to me. We all might have different standards though. I have a friend who lets her 8yo DS play rated M (for mature) shoot em up video games and thinks that is perfectly fine. I chose to limit DD's time with this kid when I went into his room to check on them and heard him say "I'm gonna shoot this guy while he's on the toilet taking a s__t so you can see his blood squirt" :scared1: Gimme Jasmine and Alladin any day.

I also don't think being either a liberal or a feminist is bad in and of itself :)

My mom was a bra burner back in the 60's when I was growing up and refused to allow Barbies in the house. Now she is the first one in line at Toys R Us buying the latest Barbie for DD. Go figger. :confused3
I don't know how old the author is, but she might mellow out when she has DGDs of her own.
 
I consider myself to be for gender equality...but these are the type of people that give the term "feminist" a bad name! I mean, attacking princesses? What's next? Baby dolls that promote having children instead of climbing the corporate ladder? Banning toy kitchens in favor of toy laptops and briefcases?

A child is not shaped by what toys they play with or what movies they watch. But by who buys them those toys and who watches those movies with them! It's the parents who are their biggest role models. Not Cinderella! My husband and I do not allow our daughters to play with Bratz dolls as we believe they glamorize growing up too soon. But princesses....heck I love the princesses! I must be a bad feminist because my daughter's room is COMPLETELY princess! And I think the princesses are good heroines for girls to look up too. They are kind, they speak eloquently, and they are beautiful inside as well as out.

Funny story: The other day my dd 6 and I were playing barbies. She decided her barbie needed a husband, so I volunteered the Ken doll I was holding. she looked at him and said "you'll do. You can start tomorrow, ok?"
 
"She wants children to live in reality, not fantasy. " What the heck is wrong with a little fantasy in a childs life???? So called 'reality' is pushed on us every day in the media. And in my book that certainly is no improvement to child care!
I Feel sorry for her kids - no theme parks, no fairs, no Disney Movies, no fiction books, and certainly no ogres or bad guys, no pretend games, no dressup stuff- I guess they have to watch CNN every day, and read history books.
For the record, I gave both of my granddaughters the opportunity to go to the boutique , get the hair/makeup thing, and get the dresses, and both opted out - just not their thing.
 
I don't buy it. My DD is the girliest of girlie girls and she was always a Disney princess at Halloween. One Halloween (I think it was her Belle year) a house in our neighborhood went all out with the decorations: spider webs everywhere, fog machine, spooky sounds, the whole enchilada. Their teen-aged son was hiding in the yard dressed all in black and and reaching out to grab the ankles of unsuspecting trick or treaters as they went up to the house. Our little group consisted of DS (around 6, I'd say), his friends and my little 3 year old DD. The "big kids" wouldn't have anything to do with that house. My Belle just hiked up her ball gown, walked straight up to the grabber and kicked him right in the stomach! She may look all sweet and helpless but that girl's not depending on anyone but herself when it comes to getting what she wants.

16 years later she's a manicured, pedicured, tight jeans wearing sorority girl. She also has a 4.0 in the Honors College, is studying pre-med and still doesn't take any cr*p from anyone. Only now when she kicks you in the gut she's wearing stilettos.

Jennifer
 
How pathetic! Just more liberal, feminist BS. Let children be children!!!!!

whoa.....for the record, i don't think there's anything wrong with being liberal or a feminist....especially in light of the study that was just published today on the fact that just one year out of college, women earn less than their male peers (and the gaps only widens with time), maybe we need a few more of those "feminist liberal" types around....

back to topic, i do think it's important to make sure our daughters see all the possibilities in the world around them....they can be the princess mulan or be the warrier mulan...and be just as good at both! i was raised on the disney princesses myself (sleeping beauty is my fave!) and i don't think i was damaged by it! although i think i have a much healthier view on femininity since my introduction to feminist thought/theory. i just think an ongoing dialogue is important....about all of the images we are consuming, kids & adults alike.
 
I am a feminist, I am a liberal. And by the way I also have a Women's Studies Degree.

Disclaimer made, I have no problem with the Disney Princess thing. I think it's an absolute genius marketing ploy by Disney. As long as girls know that happily ever after doesn't mean waiting for a prince to come and rescue them.


Personally I'm a Tinkerbell girl and always have been. Maybe it's the sassy and *****y attitude. :rolleyes: Though if the newly single Prince Williiam came knocking on my door tomorrow, I might just change my mind. :laughing:
 
I am a feminist, I am a liberal. And by the way I also have a Women's Studies Degree.

Disclaimer made, I have no problem with the Disney Princess thing. I think it's an absolute genius marketing ploy by Disney. As long as girls know that happily ever after doesn't mean waiting for a prince to come and rescue them.


Personally I'm a Tinkerbell girl and always have been. Maybe it's the sassy and *****y attitude. :rolleyes: Though if the newly single Prince Williiam came knocking on my door tomorrow, I might just change my mind. :laughing:

i'm a wmst minor! (and seriously considering pursuing a masters in the subject!) glad to know there are kindred spirits around!

i definately agree with your point toward disney's marketing genius! and i really do think they've made some strides forward with the princess genre...i'm definately interested in seeing how the newest princess in the collection turns out! like i said before, i just think its important to give girls a balance....and let them pick what kind of girl they want to be.
 
I've said it once and I'll say it a thousand times, we're in an age of over-analyzation and sensationalism.

We analyze things that don't need analyzing and we sensationalize everything.


Those were just the words I was looking for but could not find!

I totally agree!
 
Disney Princesses are perfectly fine and have really cause no problem at all. What I think is wrong is the princess "attitude" that is glorified by the media where woman and girls claim that they are better and prettier and etc than others.

My role model for a good while growing up was indeed a princess - Princess Diana. A woman of grace, elegance, beauty ... and most of all, compassion for others!

Sometimes I think that is over looked these days in a ME ME ME ME ME ME world.
 
As usual, I think the most important determinant in a child's eventual maturation is his/her parents.

For example, my sister and I were certainly brought up watching Cinderella, etc. She grew up to be a passive, spoiled, "princess" incapable of taking care of herself and literally expected a man to rescue her from the drudgery of real life (like, say, a job). I grew up to be a fairly assertive person who relies pretty much on myself. Difference? How we were raised.

I essentially raised myself from the age of 5, with the aid of grandparents and some wonderful teachers who gave a crap. She was spoiled rotten by my parents from the moment she was born and they bailed her out of every difficulty in life. (My father once drove 8 hours to change her tire when she was 25 years old. And she had AAA!) She became a passive 'princess' because that is what my parents trained her to be. (Let me note: This is a truth my parents acknowledged as a huge mistake when my sister was about 30 and they realized what kind of person my sister was. I should also add, that she finally grew up when my parents died and she had no other choice.)

Watching movies and dressing up no more makes a girl a princess/porn star, than watching Star Wars and dressing up like Chewbacca turns a boy into an overgrown dog. I loved Barbie when I was a kid -- I never thought I should have a body like hers; for crying out loud at 7 years old I knew Barbie was a doll, not real!

Movies and toys simply do not have as much power as this so-called expert gives to them. Parents have the most power, followed by peer groups. If she's concerned about girl's body image -- which, I agree, is a critical issue in our society today -- then her energy would be better directed toward encouraging parenting that teaches healthy eating and exercise habits. It's far worse to have a father telling his daughters that they're growing up to be fat and no guy will ever want them when their skinny selves reach for an extra breadstick than by watching Snow White. It's far worse to allow your daughter to hang out with girls who have body image problems than to allow her to watch Pocahontas. It's far worse to have a boy watch his father abuse his mother than to watch a movie. Kids can separate reality from fiction and what they usually mimic is reality. So if parents want a certain reality for their kids, then that is the reality they need to model. Or as the old saying goes, "Kids learn what they live."
 
Mind you I'm 23 and not a parent, BUT, this really seems like one more idea detracting from the fact that children grow up with the values they are taught in the home.

I grew up with Belle and Ariel and a soccer ball between my feet. My parents taught me that I could have many interests, that I should respect myself and others and be thoughtful and considerate. I was also taught to stick up for myself, and did so on many occasions in an appropriate manner.

As many other commenters have said, nurturing an active imagination is a healthy thing in a child and if little girls are happy dressing up as one of the Princesses, it's tons better than dressing like a provacative pop star (why do 6 year olds know who the Pussycat Dolls are?!)

Society completely baffles me - the Disney Princesses may gallavant around in beautiful poofy dresses, and have their hair done and look pretty, but respectively they stick up for their country and family (Mulan), value education and a strong sense of self (Belle), work hard at the tasks given them and remain kind to others (Cindy), dream of being the seemingly impossible and not being afraid to pursue those dreams (Ariel) ... many of those same princesses she's attacking do have lessons that little girls can learn from!

Perhaps she should be much more concerned with the unrealistic dimensions of Barbie, a woman who always seems to need Ken nearby, or those ridiculous Bratz dolls who really do look like 6 year old "porn stars"

and BTW, this princess watching little girl grew up to graduate from college with honors, while competing on the varsity track team, completed her masters degree and is still active as an alum in her sorority. I'm independent and successful - and have never owned a shirt claiming to be "spoiled" or a "porn star"!

how ridiculous!
 
Uh- nice article- sheesh. :headache: :rolleyes1

"the girl who is wearing 'Princess' across her chest when she's three be wearing 'Spoiled' across her chest when she's six, and 'Porn Star' when she is 12"
 
:laughing: Hey... Don't Princess' become Queens? Ya know.... The strong female type who can run a country and call all the shots?
 
AAAAAAAAH~ Stupidity run rampant AGAIN.

Newsflash...girls don't grow up to be princesses as an occupation any more than boys grow up to be a pirate. They are kids. They enjoy roleplay. They are creative.

Let them be, they have the rest of their lives to be serious.
 















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top