I took friends resort hopping at WDW. When I go resort hopping, I like to go to AKL and VWL - because those resorts have, in my opinion, the best theming. BWV is my
DVC home, and I like it there, but I don't think it has a lot of WOW. So I introduced my friends to the idea of resort hopping, and we did a little - then they were on their own. We were all at a conference together.
They came back, and to my surprise of all the resorts they visited, they were blown out of the water by the Boardwalk. They could not stop raving about the resort.
Some of the preferred views are lousy - its why we always book standard or Boardwalk - and why it pays to be a BWV owner.
Some of the walks to the room are long, but so are the walks from one end of any resort at WDW to the other - there isn't a small resort at WDW. BWV has the advantage (in my mind) of having air conditioned hallways to walk through.
Every room I've ever been in at BWV has had minor maintenence issues, but from other people's postings, those aren't unique to BWVs.
I think the carpets are due for replacement - the nap on them is worn, but I didn't spot any tears or places the nap had been completely worn away when I was there in June. They do get walked on a lot - and they are a strange color and pattern that is made to look "sandy" and sometimes looks "dirty" even when it isn't.