Seriously Sy, did you even read my post? lol

We had AP's, they were expiring, we told the girls we weren't renewing and THEY said "Mom, we will give up birthdays and Christmas if we can keep our AP's" I NEVER told them that would happen, I NEVER asked them to give anything up, THEY volunteered. We ultimately said no because we decided we need to pay some debt off first, after all we did take 14 trips in 12 months.

And yes, we paid cash and used gift cards and rewards a lot but we also chose to charge some of the expenses so we need to pay those off before we can (in good conscience) go again.
And FTR, my girls do have patience, in fact they have a LOT of patience and neither of them would have any difficulties waiting for a trip to DL as a gift. Also, if we were doing that we would be going around the time of their birthdays so they would know well in advance "no parties, we are doing DL instead" and I can assure with 100000000% certainty that they would be absolutely fine with that! My girls are as into DL as I am, which IMO is a good thing.

I wish you would just read what I posted instead of interpreting what you wanted, I also explained that they gave up neither Christmas nor birthdays, just that they had offered to do so because they would rather go to DL than have material gifts. We are very family oriented and we do a lot of things together, that matters to all of us more than getting gifts.

Can I just take a moment and say "I have the BEST kids in the WORLD!!!!" My girls are so grounded and so self-sacrificing and I really don't know how I got so lucky....altho DD8 just come and tell me that DD12 is "getting on my nerves" LOL
Thanks Sherry, yes, we did have AP's and we were all sad when we made the choice to let them expire.

And we did stay at the HoJo or used our timeshare points so our stays were much cheaper after we upgrade, we went for long weekends (taking off on Friday and leaving Thursday after we were home from work) we ate CS or made our own meals, we took snacks in and our own water bottles. I also belong to MyPoints and was able to get gift certificates to restaurants in the area so we were able to save that way as well. You don't have to have a ton of money to make a trip to DL memorable, you just have to be together and have fun. And you know, we did and we loved it.

And we can't wait to pay off some of our debt so we can start going back. Maybe not 14 times in 12 months but I would happily settle for 4 trips a year. LOL
Thanks Jernysgirl, for reading the post.

I would be super happy to get a trip to DL as a gift, no matter when it was given to me....heck I'd be happy to get an IOU this Christmas for a trip next Christmas! LOL Yes, I'm a diseyphile and I'm proud of it!