I am so overwhelmed.

[CheapMom]

Last time I checked prices on those cabins they were around $250 - $300. They do look nice though.

 

[MiaSRN62]

DVC Points would be the cheapest way to go. Go over to the DVC Rent and Trade board and see whats available. You should at least be able to rent at Saratoga Springs or Old Key West. Good luck

Based on renting points from a DVC Member :
I think this will be over the OP's budget as well. Even a 1 bedroom at OKW, which has 1 queen bed and then a sleeper sofa in the bedroom is going to run $200/night Sun-Thurs and then jump to $480/night for Fri-Sat night. The 2 bedrooms would run $270/$640. The nice thing about the 1 bedroom villas (if you can swing it) is that you get a full kitchen, full balcony, washer/dryer in room and jacuzzi tub. But I worked the rates out figuring on $10/point at OKW which offers the lowest points of all the DVC resorts.

So I think the OP got the best deal (that fits her budget) with the 2 value rooms and FL resident rate. Have a great time and happy upcoming anniversary.

 

[tubachick]

I would suggest looking into renting DVC points if you really want to stay on property.