I am a total reality TV junkie (Survivor, The Bachelor, Amazing Race, Top Model, Project Runway, Top Chef, etc, etc, etc), but I just can't get into American Idol.
I like the other shows because of the challenges, the mind games, and the "fly-on-the-wall" voyeurism aspect. Fascinating, as Spock would say. I tried to watch AI, but it just seems so... dull. No big twists, no fun trash talk, just mediocre songs sung by pretty good amateur singers, judges who don't really have any say in the matter, and looooots of filler.
apopogies to folks who love the show- I just don't get it

.