I have seen here that the DDP is a huge benefit if you eat at a lot of TS restaurants. I am still not clear on how to really make it work for me. I am planning a 10 day vacation and do like to eat at quite a few TS restaurants. Enough that the Ts options on the regular dining plan would be used up by the end of day 4. However, I do not want to spend ALL my time sitting down and eating. The DDP includes 3 TS meals every day- correct? And it seems to = about $64.80 per person per day. I see that if I were to eat at Chef Mickey's (breakfast), San Angel Inn (lunch) and 1900 Park Fare (dinner) every day it would save me money. These are just examples, mind you. And, having done the math, I just don't see how to make it work. I am very OCD and a meticulous planner. I look at the most recent menus possible to calculate costs. I feel confident in guesstimating what will be spent on food.
Are there pros I am not considering? I guess I could just get the basic dining plan and only use the TS meals for those that are most expensive. Is this what most people do?
What you seem to be missing is the value of signature dinners on the deluxe plan. We very rarely eat 3 meals in a day on vacation, but the deluxe plan worked very well for us because we used it for a lot of 2 credit meals. On the regular plan, 2 credit meals are generally a poor value because of the lack of appetizers and the fact that they aren't quite twice as expensive as one credit meals. They are a fine use of credits on the deluxe plan, though.
To give you an idea, this is what our deluxe plan trip looks like for May:
Day 1 - Narcoosees dinner (2 credits)
Day 2 - Teppan Edo lunch (1 credit)
Marrakesh dinner (1 credit)
Day 3 - Artist Point dinner (2 credits)
Day 4 - Yak & Yeti lunch (1 credit)
Chef Mickey dinner (1 credit)
Day 5 - Tokyo Dining lunch (1 credit)
Le Cellier dinner (1 credit)
Day 6 - Cinderella's Royal Table lunch (2 credits)
Ohana dinner (1 credit)
Day 7 - California Grill dinner (2 credits)
Day 8 - Brown Derby lunch (2 credits)
Kona dinner (1 credit)
Day 9 - Kona breakfast (1 credit)
That uses up 19 of the 24 credits we have per person for the trip, but as you can see we aren't planning on spending all our time eating. The rest of the credits will be used for last minute TS or for CS. And as far as value, the above meals adds up to slightly more than the cost of the plan, so the mugs, snacks, and unplanned meals are all over and above the breakeven point.
We did have a lot of snack credits leftover at the end of our first deluxe dining trip, but that was partly because of the circumstances of the trip (I was pregnant, avoiding unnecessary sugar & caffeine, and still in that uneasy stomach phase). Its a safe bet that I'll be trying a lot more snacky goodies on this trip! And leftover snack credits are easy to deal with - hit the Confectionary on Main Street, Goofy's Candy Co. or even the resort gift shop and get some Disney goodies to take the magic home with you.