How reputable is Jim Hill?

aristocatz

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 22, 2009
Messages
4,887
I listen to his podcasts, and he always has such interesting news & info about upcoming park & movie projects. Is he a reputable source? I'm not sure if he has ever worked for Disney, but I think he is/was a reporter in Orlando (?)
 
He has never worked for Disney AFAIK. He's an uber-fanboy. Years ago on his blog I think he mentioned that he tried to develop a screenplay based on Haunted Mansion. So he's a wannabe screenwriter or a one-time fan-fiction author or something.

He seems to have one or two contacts with people who work for Disney which is where he gets his rumors. Or maybe he only knows people who know people so he gets it second or third hand. But I think that most of the Disney history stories he tells are based on public sources ... books about Disney history, interviews and reminiscences of Disney legends, etc.

Lately he's also been invited to journalist previews of attractions and restaurants at Universal and I got the impression from listening to the way that he described these events on the podcast with Len Testa that his usual M.O. is to lean heavily on publicly available information, but to present it in a confidential tone that implies that he's got the real inside dope. He's not misleading or dishonest in any way, it's just his natural excitement and pride at getting to go to these things and hear the stories.

These are only my impressions from reading a little bit of his stuff and listening to him occasionally. He's an entertaining guy but you have to try to parse what he says to try to figure out where he gets his info. Part of the obfuscation is hucksterism, part of it is trying to protect his sources ... assuming he has any.

I wouldn't worry too much about anything that he says about the future, except I'm kind of curious (like everyone else) to see if he called the DHS story correctly. Basically he said that some concrete additions to Pixar Place will be announced shortly, but that yet again this year, only vague generalities about "big things" will be announced about Star Wars in DHS. He implied that the people concerned with this are embarrassed at the lack of progress but the blame goes back to the board of directors for tearing up all of their previous proposals/plans. He said that the Disney spin on this is, "it's actually good news ... they rejected the plans because they were not elaborate enough". It sounds more like kicking the can down the road to me ... but ... whatever ...

In around a month I guess we'll know which Disney rumor-monger has the best information ...
 
Jim is very good with Disney history. However when it comes to Disney news and rumors he reports anything and everything he hears. That is his biggest problem and makes him unreliable when it comes to things like that. Lately he has reported that Star Wars is back on the drawing board and avatar is behind schedule both are untrue but actually were true about a year or so ago just not now.
 
I love lessening to Jim Hill's Podcast mainly to learn about some new facts about the past history of Disneyland. Such as the hippie invasion during the late 60's and early 70's.
 

How reputable is Jim Hill?

81f2deb5142749624159709399_700wa_0.gif
 
/
As a historian, I don't know that there's anyone better.

As far as rumors, he just repeats every rumor he hears. Which is fine by me, because I know that going in.
You should check out WDWRadio it's another podcast website dedicated to Disney.
 
You should check out WDWRadio it's another podcast website dedicated to Disney.
Wdw radio I would not recommend to anyone because Lou Mongello never says anything negative about Disney and never mentions any of the competition around. Because of this he often gets comped from Disney for tickets, rooms, etc. Lou and the podcast and very good it's just you have to realize Disney isn't perfect.
 
My stance is that there are no "Disney insiders"...

Because the corporate structure is and has been controlled 99% by a single Individual since Easter 1994...
So even though they have hundreds of thousands of employees, there is no level of trust/certainty on any of them.

Honestly, read the wsj and you are just as likely to be right on Disney predictions as anything you'll get from an insider these days. The days of them doing anything visionary/bold are long over IMHO.
 
I listen to all the big podcasts-Jim and Len, Be Our Guest, WDW Radio, Wedway, Dis, etc...I find his to be the most informative in terms of upcoming projects (I am tied between him and Wedway for WDW history). I find his ideas or rumors interesting, but its hard to tell if his sources are reputable.

I thought I remembered a story a while back that he appointed himself a Disney your guide and was charging guests for tours inside the parks, but got in trouble with Disney for it because he was not affiliated with Disney.

He talked about Star Wars Land and the name changing for DHS a while back, but I guess time will tell how right or wrong he is.....
 
My stance is that there are no "Disney insiders"...

Because the corporate structure is and has been controlled 99% by a single Individual since Easter 1994...
So even though they have hundreds of thousands of employees, there is no level of trust/certainty on any of them.
I don't follow this at all. Can you expand a bit?
 
I listen to all the big podcasts-Jim and Len, Be Our Guest, WDW Radio, Wedway, Dis, etc...I find his to be the most informative in terms of upcoming projects (I am tied between him and Wedway for WDW history). I find his ideas or rumors interesting, but its hard to tell if his sources are reputable.

I thought I remembered a story a while back that he appointed himself a Disney your guide and was charging guests for tours inside the parks, but got in trouble with Disney for it because he was not affiliated with Disney.

He talked about Star Wars Land and the name changing for DHS a while back, but I guess time will tell how right or wrong he is.....
Usually me of his rumors are right but because he tells so many and everything he hears that makes it harder. His sources seem to be at least a few months behind in what is actually happening.
 
My stance is that there are no "Disney insiders"...

Because the corporate structure is and has been controlled 99% by a single Individual since Easter 1994...
So even though they have hundreds of thousands of employees, there is no level of trust/certainty on any of them.

I don't follow this at all. Can you expand a bit?

I read this as a reference to Eisner's consolidation of power as CEO after Frank Wells' untimely death (which happened Easter weekend in 1994). Since that time, Disney has seemingly run under a "strong CEO" corporate structure, with one individual (Eisner, then Iger) calling most of the shots.
 
My stance is that there are no "Disney insiders"...

Because the corporate structure is and has been controlled 99% by a single Individual since Easter 1994...
So even though they have hundreds of thousands of employees, there is no level of trust/certainty on any of them.

Honestly, read the wsj and you are just as likely to be right on Disney predictions as anything you'll get from an insider these days. The days of them doing anything visionary/bold are long over IMHO.

This.

I had and have friends all over within Disney. Even they don't know what's going on, usually until a day before it happens. And a couple of them are high up in management within the parks.

At one point I had a contact that does web design for Disney say that they were in meetings about bringing Beastly Kingdom back into the fold, they were doing site design and everything.....then it all stopped.

Rumors are fun, but I take them all with a grain of salt. And that's from all sources.
 
My stance is that there are no "Disney insiders"...

Because the corporate structure is and has been controlled 99% by a single Individual since Easter 1994...
So even though they have hundreds of thousands of employees, there is no level of trust/certainty on any of them.

Honestly, read the wsj and you are just as likely to be right on Disney predictions as anything you'll get from an insider these days. The days of them doing anything visionary/bold are long over IMHO.

I can guarantee you that there are people on Disney message boards like this one that have gotten access to information about Disney projects that has not been made public. Now we can debate how often this happens, but it has definitely happened.
 
The problem is that many of the future projects he talks about never make it beyond the very early design or just discussion stages.
 
I personally take it with a grain of salt. There aren't actual announcements happening so it's fun to think about what could possibly be in store for the future. I actually wish there were more speculation/rumor podcasts like his.
 
I read this as a reference to Eisner's consolidation of power as CEO after Frank Wells' untimely death (which happened Easter weekend in 1994). Since that time, Disney has seemingly run under a "strong CEO" corporate structure, with one individual (Eisner, then Iger) calling most of the shots.

Yep...that

The death of roy Disney and any "family influence" on the board of directors has not helped matters either...

Though Iger doesn't act like the open "boardroom bully" routine that Eisner pulled...the board is all schills now...which wasnt the case for Eisner and held him in check for a significant portion of his reign.

Now it's drinking scotch with stock rating agency reps and laughing at the incoming receipts...it seems to be.
 
Last edited:
I can guarantee you that there are people on Disney message boards like this one that have gotten access to information about Disney projects that has not been made public. Now we can debate how often this happens, but it has definitely happened.

I submit that there is no substance behind 99.99% of that access.

The decisions are made at the inner boardroom and anyone outside of it is not necessary/useful to the decision making process...because they are now made 100% based on corporate returns.

Wdw...65,000 employees and a ton of "titles" floating around... Has close to ZERO input into what is built/how they're operated. There is no "say" there.

So the chances of any real info eminating from Orlando is almost statistically nill.
 


/











Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top