Our tooth fairy tends to give $1 bill, quarter, nickel, dime and penny and an occasional chuck e cheese token. My oldest got a gold $1 coin and a $2 bill for her first tooth. I was out when my youngest lost her first tooth. I guess dh didn't feel it was important enough to tell me and dd was already asleep so the tooth fairy didn't come. The next night I planned on making a big deal about the tooth fairy coming. Unfortunately that night ended with my older dd breaking her arm and us spending from 6 or so at night until 5 in the morning at the hospital thus younger dd once again missing the tooth fairy. Finally 3rd night the tooth fairy did come but dd was more excited about it being the first day of kindergarten.