We sold our home of 21 years last summer. We ultimately sold it for 97% of asking; and had 3 offers in a total of 3 weeks, we went with offer #2.
It was a wild ride. We interviewed 3 agents in March 2015. We ultimately picked the agent that offered the lowest overall commission structure, not because he had a different type of commission structure, but because we liked him and his approach the best. Ironically - he suggested we put the house on the market for the highest amount. I also felt like the 2 traditional agents wanted us to make expensive changes in our house, carpeting, and adding a 2nd sink in our master bathroom. One realtor even suggested that on top of carpeting, and the sink, that we change out all hardware in the kitchen, and change out light fixtures. We were adamant that we did not want to put new carpeting in; as none of the realtors would/could guarantee that we would get our money back. The changes that the 2 traditional realtors wanted us to do would have amounted to $7K to $8K. The realtor we went with indicated that we would not need to change the carpeting, the kitchen would sell the house to the wives; the garage would sell it to the husbands. He was right on.
We saved ~$10K by going with the agent who had a fixed listing price. (We did pay the full 2.4% of the co-broker's commission). We did lose out a little on the sales price, as the market changed from March to June a little bit, but we are good with that, as in March - we had not found a house to move into. It would have been a major hassle to find a short term rental, store our stuff, and move it a second time when we did find a new house, all which would have totally stressed me out.
We had been looking for a house in a different part of the state for about 9 months, and finally found the perfect house for a couple approaching empty-nesting. Much smaller yard, and a ranch. We offered ~1.5% higher than listing price; and made our offer on our first visit to the house; 3 days after it was listed. NO REGRETS - this house is perfect for us!
We had both houses for about 2.5 weeks, which really made moving out of the first one and into the 2nd one just a breeze.