We went this past May--Mother's Day weekend--and enjoyed it very much.
Our server--was it Daria?--was very attentive, friendly & efficient.
We did go later in the evening. Often you can hedge the bets on decent service by having meals at 'off' times
I will say ask for the room furthest away from the bar area, it does get noisy!
We sat in the room up the stairs & near the fireplace, which was pleasant, but non descript (as is the whole dining room),
on the other hand there was no noise coming from the CS down the hall.
We had made ADRs that day & waited, perhaps, 5 minutes. We did take one of the latest ADRs available. We were pooped out from the parks & did not want to do the bus changing thing to go to our original ADR at another resort.
Our food was good, too. I had prime rib & sweet potato salad, DH had the filet.
DH liked Boatwrights better than the refurbed Captain's Grille Yacht Club. He also had the fillet here & said he preferred Boatwrights
Decor wise, for me, I
much preferred CGYC. The filets were comparable, too, I thought.
Scale: 1-5, 5 being outstanding, wonderful. We'll scale for WDW & not IRL
Boatwrights
Food: 4
Cleanliness: 4
Service: 5
Friendliness: 5, server; 4 reception
Ambience: 2
Wait time: 5
Would we go again? Yes. Not a 'destination' but would not hesitate.
Jean