Isn't that the same for people who do like fp+? They could say, "just because it didn't work out nicely for you, doesn't mean everyone else has had the same experience." If it's not okay to question the experience or opinion of disliking fp+, then I'm not sure why it's okay to do that to others who do like it. And yes, that is done on both sides. Cause again... This thread will end up locked soon lol.
I think you misunderstand. People aren't questioning that some people enjoy the new system, people aren't questioning that some people have gotten what they wanted, on short notice. The argument isn't "its impossible to log in the night before and find everything you want and book it" that's entirely possible.
The argument is that's not likely (particularly during mid and peak crowd levels) and not reflective of a good number of experiences we have seen posted here (by several posters now in this thread alone and not any of the "haters" I am sure you want to lump them in with). On top of that its certainly more restricted than it was under the previous system. You can make all kinds of arguments about touring styles and about how in the afternoons FPs would be gone and yadda yadda, but you didn't have to go in the afternoon, everyone had the option of going in the morning, with a clean slate of FPs, no one having the advantage of booking at 60 or 30 etc. But now if you want to ensure you get at least the 3 you want, you need to log in and book them, and yes to increase the chances of getting 3 of the rides you want, and trying to ensure the timing of them, that means there is a direct correlation to the timing of you booking your FPs ... the earlier the better.
I haven't seen a lot of people "questioning" the experience of people who have had a good time under FP+, at least not in the sense they deny their experience. ie: "You got A&E the night before you showed up, no way, not possible." I have seen a lot of people respond to such posts as "you are lucky" or "most people can't get that". Have you seen anyone say "not possible" or tell someone they didn't get the FPs they claim ? Really ? On the other hand we have people here denying, straight out, that FP+ has increased SB wait times, denying any need to book FPs in advance, Denying that you can't move around FPs (which at times, you can't), Denying that people get shut out of rides. These things are all true, and they do happen. The fact that some people ARE able to book what they want the night before, or get lucky day of and can move a Barn Stormer FP into an A&E does not mitigate the downside risk of FP+. Its not that you "HAVE" to book at 60 days out to make sure you get the attractions and times you want, its that literally everyone minute you wait decreases the chances that you will get them. Its not that you have to even use FP+, but if you don't you will be waiting in longer lines for many attractions than you would have before FP+. Especially if you were the type to be unwilling to stand in long lines before FP+. Its the natural outcome of the new system.