My suggestion, and this is purely my personal opinion having been to both, would be the Hoop-De-Doo Revue. It is very entertaining, lively, and funny. You are not at the mercy of the weather there, since it is inside, whereas the Luau is in a "partially open to the elements" building. The seating time would totally depend on preferance for eating times, and age of those attending. I think the late seatings are much too late for the little ones. The food at the Luau is fried rice, ribs, and chicken. The meal at the Hoop-de-doo is fried chicken, corn, salad - both served family style. The hoop-de-doo is more interactive with the audience. As far as the show at the Luau, if you have seen one you have seen another. They all tend to be about the same. The meal at the hoop-de-doo is served during the show. If my memory serves me correctly, you eat first and then see the show at the Luau. I can't remember the exact pricing, but I think they are both about the same. Maybe someone else can elaborate more on that aspect. You will not be disappointed in the Hoop-de-doo; it is a must see and do.