I had a similar thread and decided on Hoop De Doo based on everyone's comments, haven't done either though and am looking forward to Hoop De Doo.
Whispering Canyon ROCKS!!! We LOVED this restaraunt. Great food, and you laugh the entire meal, SO much fun. The kids had a blast, especially participating in the horse races around the restaraunt, don't miss it. We ate there for breakfast and dinner and had great meals at both.
Lesley