We sailed on the Wish earlier this month. It was our first cruise, ever. We were not converts. Arendelle was loud, and yet I could not understand what performers were singing because the guests were too loud. Marvel was pretty entertaining for a first time, but it didn't have a lot of content going for it, and I can't imagine I'd be that interested in doing it a second time. The food was pretty mid, except a couple entrees, which were excellent. Full disclosure: we're vegan. The Oceaneer Club didn't do it for our kid.
Lookout Cay was not worth paying for a whole cruise to go back, despite thinking it might have been more fun in nicer weather. The lines on board for characters were still pretty long for me and our kid (both AuDHD), so we skipped all of those. And without those things and Oceaneer Club, there wasn't much more to us to do. We're not into being human soup (the pools). I will say that we got away with AquaMouse
once because we could see Encanto playing on the Funnel Vision screen most of the time. Personally, despite AquaMouse being mildly diverting, I wasn't willing to wait half an hour again to put myself through the loud audio at the beginning of the ride. The only thing I found diverting enough to return to a few times was trivia, but there were definitely some ringers on board that took some of the fun out of it--I was finally able to win one when most guests were in the Little Mermaid show, which I left, so there were only 5 of us at Luna for the Pixar trivia. These trivia events seemed like excuses to sell more alcoholic beverages (which I don't drink), though to be fair many people participated without a beverage, and I did have one great host 2-3 times (Sasha).
Long story short: we just weren't wowed for the money. Perhaps we're not the target audience. I could see us trying another cruise ship again for a specific destination we want to see anyway, like Alaska, but otherwise the consensus here is that we'd rather spend our Disney vacation funds into resort vacations.
